• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

How to get in deep trouble telling the truth

Pilgrim

Supporting Member
Jul 8, 2004
20,097
20,446
Fort Collins, Colorado
www.colocougs.org
The estimable Robert A. Heinlein wrote this in Stranger in a Strange Land (one of his characters speaking):
“I do know that the slickest way to lie is to tell the right amount of truth--then shut up.”

It's also possible to get in deep trouble telling the truth. Let's see what examples people will offer.....

good-eyesight.jpg
 
In my world as a bass player there's one hard line I draw in every band. Don't sing a song you have no business singing. Period. If you have to drop a Journey song 4 whole steps you have no business singing Journey. If you sound like Greg Allman you have no business singing Prince.

Nobody cares what your favorite song is. Nobody cares what you WANT to sing.

So, in my world....

"You have no business singing that song."
 
Last edited:
The truth hits everybody.

@two fingers
Plenty of successful cover bands de-tune songs or play them in a different style live and they sound fine. Even the original bands sometimes play songs de-tuned, at different tempos or in a different style at concerts to accommodate the singer or players. Making it sound good is what it's all about.
I do understand your point though, when a musician is trying to stay faithful to the recording but can't quite pull it off it's painful to listen to and crowds don't give out A's for effort.
 
Last edited:
An exchange between our fledgeling student teacher and a girl with special needs-

ST: So who’s your favorite singer?
Girl: Christina Grimmie. She’s amazing.
ST: Oh yeah, she really was! I was so sad when she got murdered.
Girl: ...
ST: ...
Girl: ... when she what?

I intervened just in time to explain that she had a long and successful music career before retiring to live on a farm where she could chase rabbits all day and also she got a motorcycle.

Thank god that girl loved rabbits.

--^@