• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

I would like some input for using a digitech whammy pedal for guitar on a bass...

Now, I would love to have a digitech bass whammy pedal but that is out since I am not about to spend upwards of up to $800 on ebay for one so I'm thinking about the other digitech whammys for guitar. Now, I'm torn between the Digitech WH-1 Whammy and the
Digitech XP-100 Whammy-Wah. Some people say that the wh-1 sounds just as good and other says that the xp-100 is really good because it has more options. More options is cool but I am more worried about keeping my tone and having a good sound. So what does anybody think? Which one sound good and keeps tone?
 
The WH-1 is out of production and will cost probably about as much as a Bass Whammy. The WH-4 is the current model in production. I use a WH-4 and I think it sounds pretty good. There's a little bit of low end loss. Obviously not as good as a WH-1 but still pretty good. Don't know about the Whammy-Wah.
 
I used to own a WH-4, I sold it when I decided to cut down on effects, I really regret it now. A great pedal, though there are some settings the Bass Whammy and XP-100 have, that the WH-4 doesn't and vice versa (such as the harmony 5th up/1 up setting as used on some Tool songs).

If you're looking for a decent, not too expensive alternative to the Bass Whammy this is probably the best way to go.

There's a little bit of low end loss.

This is true, but it's easily solved by blending with your dry signal, though you may end up spending a bit more.
 
I had the Whammy 4 or whatever, the newest Whammy Reissue. Got some great sounds out of it with bass, it works good. A saxophone player from one of my old bands had the XP-100 Whammy Wah. That thing sounded like garbage, I tried it. Seriously, I hated it. So cheap sounding. I know some guys use them and like them, but don't compare it to the WH-4, in my experience the WH-4 blows the XP-100 out of the water.
 
I had the Whammy 4 or whatever, the newest Whammy Reissue. Got some great sounds out of it with bass, it works good. A saxophone player from one of my old bands had the XP-100 Whammy Wah. That thing sounded like garbage, I tried it. Seriously, I hated it. So cheap sounding. I know some guys use them and like them, but don't compare it to the WH-4, in my experience the WH-4 blows the XP-100 out of the water.

Thanks...I was thinking that. I have heard people say that get the xp-100 because it has all these sounds and features and all that. That is cool and all but I like to go for equipment that will sound good and is efficient.