• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Impersonation

hrodbert696

Moderator
Staff member
Gold Supporting Member
Maybe it's Halloween coming up, but help me out here;

I had a sudden idea taking a shower this afternoon (yes, that was correct... it's my day off). The university where I am now teaching is reorganizing into a structure intended to really push interdisciplinarity (that's people from different fields collaborating, to translate the academic-speak). I need to develop a work plan with my program chair and having some sort of interdisciplinary "cluster" project would be a major plus (yes, that's what they're calling it, and yes... I know...).

I'm a medieval historian and my dissertation was on Christianization, which doesn't lend itself to the interdisciplinary aspect very well (especially in the absence of a religious studies program), and isn't activating my enthusiasm (academically) like it did when I defended the dissertation ten years ago. I'm looking for something new to do. The kind of projects they want could entail both research on my part with components of teaching and co-curricular student projects.

So my mind is wandering and it drifts across the question of what I should propose in the work plan, and I'm thinking about my daughter's enthusiasm for Comicon cosplay, and that I was a theater studies undergrad, and my surprise to learn in a recent reading that already in medieval times people would dress up as King Arthur characters, which resembles modern Renaissance Faires, which themselves have a 19th century precedent...

And suddenly it all came together; "Impersonation: a history of not being yourself."

So what I'm throwing out to the TB hive mind, just to see what the net catches, is an invitation to tell me about all the instances of this kind of thing you can think of. I'm brainstorming a bunch myself but there are probably some that wouldn't occur to me. Also any resources, books, websites, anything you know of that I could use to start researching and coming up with teaching material.

For now I'm setting aside theater and movies, where there's alternate-world "acting" going on. That's probably relevant to the project but is a whole sphere to itself. What I'm more interested in is ritual and play, instances where people dress up and behave to personify characters without a formal separation from their "real life" identities.

Things that come to mind:

Chivalric dress-up at medieval jousts, Victorian medievalisms and modern Renaissance Faires
Society for Creative Anachronism
Religious (e.g. Shamanistic) personification of gods or spirits in ritual
Carnevale/Mardi Gras/Fasching
Halloween
Children's dress-up play and costume parties
Historical re-enactors, both amateur societies and as professional tourist-attractions (e.g. Plimoth Plantation or Colonial Williamsburg)
ComiCon Cosplay and LARPing.
Masqued balls
Glam rockers? KISS, David Bowie, GWAR?
Role play as a psychological/therapeutic/instructional method

I could see developing a series of articles or book on all this, collaborating with faculty from theater, psychology, or anthropology, teaching a class, and a student project that might entail both studying some of these things in modern society and maybe putting on such an event of their own.

Ideas? Hit me!
 
There are Civil War reenactors. Young people have always experimented with their identities for a while. Hippies, goths, punkers, and all kinds of other subcultures that involve looking like something or another that's not mainstream. Most of those people go on to join the mainstream and become adults after a while. Harley Davidson riders who get all decked out like they are badass biker gang members are really a dressup thing where ordinary people can become scary bikers for a few hours. There's militia guys who get all dressed up in camo like they are special forces members. Then there's people like me who have day jobs but become rock stars for a few hours every so often, even if it's just in our own minds. It's endless when you start thinking about it.
 
Last edited:
For what it's worth, I was in Los Angeles yesterday and went into a coffee shop that had a barista all made up like a character named Harley Quinn or something like that. She looked awful, which was probably the whole idea. Being completely out of touch, I had to ask he what it was all about, and she cheerfully gave me a long explanation about how she had made a video about how to look like that, and that there was some kind of Cosplay event coming up in a week and she was going to look like that again. She seemed to be really happy to explain it all to a person (me) who was clearly out of touch.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hrodbert696
Ok, this is gonna embarrass me a bit but I find when I talk to others I tend to adopt their accents a bit. I'm not sure if it's a way to make them feel more comfortable in communicating with me, but I hear myself doing it and still can't seem to stop. For what it's worth I'm told I'm very good at communicating to others and since I tend towards the gregarious side when speaking in public I suppose that helps as well.

So I guess I'm being myself while not being myself.

I can't recall hearing anyone else do it. Maybe I'm a deviant :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: hrodbert696
As an aside can we all agree the man bun top knot thing has run its course and see an end to it? Here in Sacramento it seems there is an entire mens fashion segment that takes it's cues from feudal Japan. I see it in "professionals" in suits on down to street kids. We even have a girl working for me that is sporting a top knot.
 
Maybe it's Halloween coming up, but help me out here;

I had a sudden idea taking a shower this afternoon (yes, that was correct... it's my day off). The university where I am now teaching is reorganizing into a structure intended to really push interdisciplinarity (that's people from different fields collaborating, to translate the academic-speak). I need to develop a work plan with my program chair and having some sort of interdisciplinary "cluster" project would be a major plus (yes, that's what they're calling it, and yes... I know...).

I'm a medieval historian and my dissertation was on Christianization, which doesn't lend itself to the interdisciplinary aspect very well (especially in the absence of a religious studies program), and isn't activating my enthusiasm (academically) like it did when I defended the dissertation ten years ago. I'm looking for something new to do. The kind of projects they want could entail both research on my part with components of teaching and co-curricular student projects.

So my mind is wandering and it drifts across the question of what I should propose in the work plan, and I'm thinking about my daughter's enthusiasm for Comicon cosplay, and that I was a theater studies undergrad, and my surprise to learn in a recent reading that already in medieval times people would dress up as King Arthur characters, which resembles modern Renaissance Faires, which themselves have a 19th century precedent...

And suddenly it all came together; "Impersonation: a history of not being yourself."

So what I'm throwing out to the TB hive mind, just to see what the net catches, is an invitation to tell me about all the instances of this kind of thing you can think of. I'm brainstorming a bunch myself but there are probably some that wouldn't occur to me. Also any resources, books, websites, anything you know of that I could use to start researching and coming up with teaching material.

For now I'm setting aside theater and movies, where there's alternate-world "acting" going on. That's probably relevant to the project but is a whole sphere to itself. What I'm more interested in is ritual and play, instances where people dress up and behave to personify characters without a formal separation from their "real life" identities.

Things that come to mind:

Chivalric dress-up at medieval jousts, Victorian medievalisms and modern Renaissance Faires
Society for Creative Anachronism
Religious (e.g. Shamanistic) personification of gods or spirits in ritual
Carnevale/Mardi Gras/Fasching
Halloween
Children's dress-up play and costume parties
Historical re-enactors, both amateur societies and as professional tourist-attractions (e.g. Plimoth Plantation or Colonial Williamsburg)
ComiCon Cosplay and LARPing.
Masqued balls
Glam rockers? KISS, David Bowie, GWAR?
Role play as a psychological/therapeutic/instructional method

I could see developing a series of articles or book on all this, collaborating with faculty from theater, psychology, or anthropology, teaching a class, and a student project that might entail both studying some of these things in modern society and maybe putting on such an event of their own.

Ideas? Hit me!

It's an interesting idea. Your plight reminds me of businesses frequently are told to consider when they're looking for new avenues of income, namely the anecdote about Pepsi realizing that they're not a soda drink manufacturer, they're a bottling plant. In your case, you're an historian and a medieval religious scholar so you could consider leveraging that knowledge to include historical events when an important figure put on a public face and altered history. Ghandi? MLK? Winston Churchill come to mind. Trump? Spies? Ultimately, you should probably consider who will find your analysis valuable and sponsor additional research - how to monetize it - grants.
 
Last edited: