• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Index finger pain/locking up.

gypsyfelon

Supporting Member
Oct 24, 2014
246
1
356
long island,ny
Hey folks while I’m on a roll here just curious if anybody has had this type of issue before. Index finger seems to lock up in a closed position and it’s achy at the base of my finger on the inside of my hand right around the back of the knuckle. Arthritis maybe? I’m 65 been playing about 45 years on and off. Anybody else get this? If so, what did you try? Thanks in advance.
 
Hey folks while I’m on a roll here just curious if anybody has had this type of issue before. Index finger seems to lock up in a closed position and it’s achy at the base of my finger on the inside of my hand right around the back of the knuckle. Arthritis maybe? I’m 65 been playing about 45 years on and off. Anybody else get this? If so, what did you try? Thanks in advance.

If you aren't working out in the gym as in lifting weights, your will experience more physical issues than if you did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlackCrow
I had that back in college. I think it was from poor picking technique, maybe hammering the strings too hard all night. Woodshedding with a focus on picking seemed to cure it and I haven't had a problem with it since.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dasgre0g
Think elastic bands could help?

Beat it flat with a mallet like a veal cutlet.

As suggested, it sounds like trigger-finger where the tendon develops a raised node and creates a speed-bump as it passes over adjacent structure. If you force open with the other hand, you'll probably hear & feel a distinctive "click". Mine comes and goes in terms of immobility. I'm 65, as well, and paying the dues for the follies of my youth.

Riis
 
  • Like
Reactions: Admiral Akbar
Think elastic bands could help?
It's most likely an over use issue. Adding more use to the equation is likely to make it worse, not better.

For musicians, I think these hand exercisers do more harm that good. You need exactly enough strength to push the string on to the frets with enough force so it doesn't buzz. No more. Any strength beyond that is not helping your playing. We're marathoners, not power lifters. You do see marathoners squatting 600 lbs. Just my two cents.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gypsyfelon
I have had this stiff index finger problem a number of times while playing upright bass at bluegrass jams. The problem seems to be lack of water. Playing three hours without a break at jams is the issue. Drink lots of water and take a break; washing your hands with warm water also helps.

(My finger does not bend, but stays straight and won’t move for fretting the bass. )

I have also changed strings to those with less tension and lowered the string height. Plus I now use a small amp such as a Phil Jones BG-400.
 
what i've learned from physical therapy for various muscle injuries is to exercise opposing/ ancillary muscles to the ones in question. for your case maybe use a rubber band around all your closed fingers and spread / splay out your hand against the resistance. also, yea drink water and see a hand person if you're worried about it.
upload_2024-3-5_22-23-39.jpeg
 
Last edited:
Warm Epsom Salt soak then ice it after. My hands are beat up pretty good, and it works for me. But if you feel its a true medical condition, not just wear and tear, physical therapy from a hand specialist can only help not hurt.
What he/she said- Physical Therapy, warm water soaks. I had the Trigger Finger surgery which worked.
'stenosing tenosynovitis, is a disorder characterized by catching or locking of the involved finger in full or near full flexion, typically with force. There may be tenderness in the palm of the hand near the last skin crease.' Splints, PT, surgery.
 
Something I ran into years ago and what helped me. I was playing 5 nights a week on the road. Hand cramps were an issue. Epsom Salts is good in a warm water soak but, hard to do on the road. Our guitar tech told me about this and what to check for. After his suggestion and what to look for, this was what I found.

He was right. During sleep, I had my hand balled up closed in a fist under my pillow. This was what the Tech warned me about. I started to force myself to flatten my hands while in bed all the time. Now it's just automatic. I avoid clinching either hand anymore. My hand cramps pretty much went away after short time. I started doing this years ago and still do after 50 years playing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: blastoff