• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Is this 4/4?

Tal Wilkenfeld has some new music out, and I was trying to figure out the rhythm for this piece:


What do you think it is?

Yeah it's 4/4. The band is just going out of it's way to not feature the 1 - that's why it feels so spacey. During the guitar solo, the groove it drifts into a more normal feel.

Wasn't aware of her singing either - thanks for sharing! Quite a young talent this one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass
Yeah it's 4/4. The band is just going out of it's way to not feature the 1 - that's why it feels so spacey. During the guitar solo, the groove it drifts into a more normal feel.

Wasn't aware of her singing either - thanks for sharing! Quite a young talent this one.

Great description. Add to that the beat is so not "onecentric" that it's hard to tell where the one is during the opening drum groove. I dig it. The OCD part of me can count to 4 duri g the body of the song so I don't have to poke my eyes out with an ice pick. But it's a different feel and groove at the same time.

She's maturing as a vocalist. She came from the womb being able to kill on bass.
 
Here's another one where they leave the 1 almost completely empty. The verse starts around 0:55 in, and the hi hat closing is the only think that happens on the 1. When they do finally hit the 1 it's like they opened the floodgates. Such an effective way to build and release tension.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LBS-bass
I'm sure glad I asked this here first, rather than ask online and expose my ignorance to they very person who wrote the song.


EAF114A1-9107-4A9C-B509-079A57322290.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: HaphAsSard
I'm sure glad I asked this here first, rather than ask online and expose my ignorance to they very person who wrote the song.


View attachment 3314752
Boom. I (like others here, probably), did get the rhythm as 4/4 but not the snare-on-the-one thing until hearing the more "open" part starting from 1:43, noticing what I'd provisionally (but suspiciously) identified as a missing eighth note (and an odd-time) in the last measure, then hearing the chorus switch back to the starting section with no such skip; hence an even deeper-seated suspect that my perception of the returning verse was now shifted, which rescrolling till the start of the video confirmed.