• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

James Jamerson and the sung melody

I like Gerald Veasly's commentary in the SITSOM book. He describes hearing Darling Dear on a jukebox and how it sounded like the bass was playing a duet with Michael Jackson.

I think he also said it scared him to death because up to that time he was getting by playing mostly roots and fifths.

Darling Dear is the first thing that comes to mind here. The counterpoint between bass and vocal around "To be sincere, and true love will appear..." around :56 (about 1:06 in this video) in is amazing. There's no doubt he was listening to the vocal during that.

 
Last edited:
I don't know if it was Jamerson or another Motown bassist who came up with the bass line for Jimmy Ruffin's version of What Becomes Of The Broken Hearted, but I think it's brilliant how the bass line has been condensed down to so few notes by playing thirds and fifths under some of the chords rather than following the chord structure with root notes.



I would not have had the nerve to try that if I'd been creating the bass line for that song. Whoever did it must have had a lot of confidence.

I also love how different Jamerson and Duck Dunn approached soul/R & B bass lines. They were essentially exact opposites in their approach, yet each made their bass lines work perfectly for the songs they recorded.
 
  • Like
Reactions: IamGroot
Not a Beatles fan by any means, but I think that helps me make sense of his playing a bit.

He knows his name. He said the biggest influence on his bass playing was James Jamerson.

I believe I remember JPJ once said he was influenced by JJ’s playing.
Jack Bruce was also very influenced by Jamerson:
Interview: Jack Bruce Talks Cream, Ornette Coleman & Self-Expression | Bacon's Archive

Did you know it was James Jamerson?

Not then. Nobody knew then. I met James, in fact. We became very firm friends in 1974. And I miss him. The time I did spend with him was wonderful. He gave me some of his Motown sessions in LA when he couldn't do them. I've got a track on that new book project—I did a few, but I don't know which one they ended up using. It was good fun to do. [The 1989 package of Standing In The Shadows Of Motown by Allan Slutsky, a.k.a. Dr. Licks, included Jack's take on Smokey Robinson's "Come 'Round Here (I'm The One You Need)."].

I started to hear James and started developing my bass playing in that direction. Then Marvin Gaye came over here. He'd just had his first few hits, must have been '65. Graham Bond got the job of putting the band together to do a TV show with Marvin, we were playing things like "How Sweet It Is," and I was going [sings busy Jamerson-like bassline], so he asked me to join, but unfortunately—unfortunately? Fortunately, I was getting married [laughs], and I couldn't go.

But that did encourage me that I was on the right track, because I was having a lot of problems, specially from Ginger who thought my bass playing was becoming too busy. It was just that he could hear me now. Suddenly there was a bass, and I was playing melody.

I've always thought that good music is not a melody and a block and boom-boom. To me good music is all melody—the drums should be playing tunes, the bass should be playing tunes, it should be counterpoint. I like to be able to listen to a lot of things going on, as opposed to one block—unless that's what you want. I like moving parts, and that's what a lot of the great Stax and Tamla things are. A lot of great soul music is very contrapuntal. So James Jamerson to me was Tamla Motown, as much as any of the great singers. He's what made it great, this bass player.

How was James when you met?

He was a heroin addict. The poor guy was shattered. He was a broken man, even then in '74. Because his home was Detroit, he felt, in the same way as I felt about some of the situations I've been in, that you've put your heart and your soul and your health into making something great, and when you're not wanted anymore you're just tossed aside.

That's exactly what had happened with him. A lot of the time I spent with him, he was crying. He was a very emotionally disturbed person—he'd lost his home, his way of life, he'd never had the recognition he deserved. Nobody knew who he was, apart from the people who took the trouble to find out. Very sad.

I suppose the best we can say is we have the music.

We have the music, but we don't have James. [Jamerson died in 1983 at the age of 47.] And James should be living. It's very difficult for me to talk about—being a musician, obviously I'm very much on the side of the musician. I don't mean the rock 'n' roll star, necessarily, and I certainly don't mean the accountants.

I do know that, for instance, Coleman Hawkins ended up his life playing in smoke-filled clubs, when possibly he should have been professor in some beautiful university, living the life that Von Karajan or somebody could have chosen to live. You know, a quiet life with no financial problems and not having to go out and earn his bread by playing in clubs at an age when he wasn't up for it. He should have been revered, that's my feeling on it.
 
I heard an XM radio interview with Brian and Eddie Holland from a little over a year ago. When asked about the Bass sound on Motown recordings they said there were often two Bassists on a session. One was usually Jamerson but they were unable to remember who the other was. The second Bassist would hold down a simple rhythm pattern while Jamerson would fill in around it. As great as Jamerson is we can now never be sure if he was solely responsible for the Bass on any given classic Motown songs.
 
I heard an XM radio interview with Brian and Eddie Holland from a little over a year ago. When asked about the Bass sound on Motown recordings they said there were often two Bassists on a session. One was usually Jamerson but they were unable to remember who the other was. The second Bassist would hold down a simple rhythm pattern while Jamerson would fill in around it. As great as Jamerson is we can now never be sure if he was solely responsible for the Bass on any given classic Motown songs.

Which leads to the ages old Jamerson vs. Kaye controversy.........
 
  • Like
Reactions: lowdownthump
While we’re on this.

Much has been written about Jameson’s tone, emphasizing p bass, flat wounds, one finger, foam mute, open strings.

But the biggest ingredient I hear is overdrive on his recordings. Which I wasn’t prepared for when I realized it was so up front. That and maybe the heavy gauge flatwounds.

Interesting, I’ve a Fender Rumble, with a “vintage” switch that puts you well into that tonal realm. The button gives you compression and low pass filter at 400 Hz. Wooly and dark.
 
That's not Jamerson, it's Wilton Felder.

I used to think Jamerson played on all the early Motown tracks but now we know that wasn't the case. It's reasonable to assume that because he and Bob Babbit sounded alike, at least recorded tone wise.
Actually, that bassline was by someone else. Wilton Felder played on that song.

Yeah, I know. Hence the silly GIF pic. It's one of those miss-attributed parts, people often assume was Jamerson.

Apparently Felder was recently back from the Crusades.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JTE and IamGroot