When you say volume drop, does the tone get quieter or do you also lose a lot of low end?
If you are loosing low end, and you would know it, I mean like all the low end, then the pickups are out of phase, and that's when you want to change the polarity.
But you do lose some volume with some blend pots at the center detent.
One important thing to look for is that you wired the blend pot the right way. It matters which lug is ground, because when measured from the wiper (center lug) you will see a lot of resistance to one outside lug, and very little at the other. For a 250K blend, you might see 240K from the center to one of the outside lugs, and 10K to the other side. You want the lug with the most resistance to go to ground. The other side is hot. The other deck of the pot will be reversed.
If you wire the pot up the wrong way you get a drop off in the middle.
Here's the correct way to wire them up:
Invalid Link Removed
Also, some blend pots just don't work well. I like the M/N taper pots sold at Allparts and GuitarJonesUSA.
If it's a polarity issue, just swap the hot and ground wired on one of the pickups.