U-Bass preamp/di's... Fishman Platinum Pro Bass vs. Radial PZ-Pre
I've been super-happy with the Fishman with the U-Bass, but I 've recently started doubling on upright bass & the Fishman just sounded 'ok' with my upright. It has an obvious baked-in eq that kinda muffles/reduces some of the resonances of the upright. It doesn't sound
bad, just not as much potential. The Fishman almost masks some of my intonation and technique mistakes.
Both have similar feature sets, with the Radial having more switching/routing capabilities & the Fishman having more power options (phantom, battery or adapter - the Radial is adapter only).
Both have 10meg input impedance (switchable on the Radial) and similar output strength. The Radial has a very convenient "mute" button whereas the Fishman you have to turn the volume down on it all the way if you want to unplug/switch your instrument. The Fishman has better overall eq options with an infinitely adjustable HPF (the Radial has only 2 settings, the most useful bass setting is 80hz) and more bands - but- the Radial's notch filter is better at locating feedback.
I'll leave out all the fine-detail comparisons to say that after spending a couple of hours -
I prefer the Fishman with the U-Bass (but only a little) and prefer the Radial with the upright by a more significant margin. The Radial exhibits a more 'honest' transparent sound which I like to capture the uprights idiosyncrasies, but the "baked-in" eq of the Fishman just really seems perfect for the subsonic boom of the U-Bass. I suppose I'm using the instruments for different vibes, of course!
The little Fishman BII belt pack sounds great with both but doesn't have the amount of features being so small. It's indispensable to me for how well it works as a simple acoustic bass buffer, so it goes wherever either instrument goes!
The Aggie TH350 through SL112 is
to die for with either acoustic bass, btw!
I've also been using an Empress ParaEQ which also works really well with both despite it's less optimal impedance rating. I'll save that guy for the studio though!