• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Legator NB5FP or Acacia Atlas opinions

Anyone have or played a Legator NB5FP 2020 or Acacia Atlas? I'm in the market for a 5 string fanned fret and am curious to hear opinions on them.

Basses
[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

I've played a dingwall NG-2 and loved the feel but not the biggest fan of the pups and they're a bit more expensive. Also more difficult to find used ones in the price ranges as the above. With the other two brands I feel it would be easier and less costly to change the stock pups if I don't like them.
 
I just placed an order for an acacia atlas 5 today. Should be done sometime in November, haven’t played one, but between the info I could find on them and how awesome Scott was to deal with thus far, I have a feeling it’s going to be a pretty great finished product.
 
I just placed an order for an acacia atlas 5 today. Should be done sometime in November, haven’t played one, but between the info I could find on them and how awesome Scott was to deal with thus far, I have a feeling it’s going to be a pretty great finished product.

Yeah Scott was really quick to respond when I reached out for info. I'm sure their basses are awesome. I ended up going with the Legator for the fishman pups, aesthetic, and price. Mine should arrive in late September and also have a great feeling about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Parker Klein
I'm curious if you received your Legator NB5FP. Looks like a great option at the price point but very little real world reviews yet. Legator doesn't have the best track record quality wise but it seems like this may be a big step up. Please be so kind to share your initial thoughts. Thanks!
 
I'm curious if you received your Legator NB5FP. Looks like a great option at the price point but very little real world reviews yet. Legator doesn't have the best track record quality wise but it seems like this may be a big step up. Please be so kind to share your initial thoughts. Thanks!

They had some COVID and customs related delays. I called last Friday and they got their basses in. Should be getting it at the end of the week hopefully. Yeah I didn’t know about their track record until recently but I’m gonna stay optimistic! I’ll for sure put down my thoughts when I finally get it.
 
Seems to me the Ninja and the Atlas are two different beasts: one is a production bass that you buy online, either direct from Legator or from MF (currently 10% off), the other is custom (or at least semi-custom), for which you place an order, and wait for it to be built and shipped.

My concerns with the Ninja would be Legator's reputation for uneven build quality, as well as trying to find an E string that will reach the tuner on that (rather unattractive) 4 + 1 REVERSE headstock. Even if you find a set of strings that are long enough for all strings, your choice of string sets will be pretty limited. I think if you're going to go 36" multiscale, a headless bass will give you more string options.
 
They had some COVID and customs related delays. I called last Friday and they got their basses in. Should be getting it at the end of the week hopefully. Yeah I didn’t know about their track record until recently but I’m gonna stay optimistic! I’ll for sure put down my thoughts when I finally get it.


I got the bass last night and it's interesting that's for sure. There are some definite pros and cons.

The neck is awesome. I'm used to fender 4 spacing/shape and gloss finishes but this thing felt natural to play immediately. The rosewood fingerboard looks unusual and kind of looks like fake wood but it could be the way they sanded it. Regardless it feel and plays great.

It took a bit to setup comfortably but it's good now. This is also my first 5 string so to it took me longer to get the feel right. The truss rod adjustment wheel at the bottom made adjustments super easy. Bridge isn't bad either as it was easy to adjust and I have no complaints here.

The Fishman setup is sick. It has a ton of variety between the 3 voices and single coil tap. I think I'm going to add a third one in the middle position so I can get a full pickup spectrum. I play mostly electronic, funk, rock, and metal but you can play any sort of style on this thing. EQ is great too it's more clear and neutral versus any other preamp I've played. The control cavity also has a good deal of space which is great for me as I want to add a killswitch, third pickup separate voice switch, and battery pack potentially.

There is some quality control issues. The big one is the fingerboard has a tiny crack near one of the inlays. Looks like they sealed it with glue or epoxy. It doesn't effect playability but this is not something you would expect from a brand new instrument. The truss rod adjustment wheel looks rusted. One of the inlays in the upper registers is kinda dirty and that dirt is glued in. Not a huge deal but there are some wood shavings in the electronics cavity. It is a bit neck heavy with the body being a bit too light for the neck. It's not extreme but it's there.

It was also supposed to include a deluxe gigbag but they forgot that or perhaps they shipped it separately. I was supposed to receive an email on shipping but they rushed it out so I was pleasantly surprised when It came in. I'm going to call shortly about the gig bag and fingerboard crack as they are just opening.

Overall this is very fun to play and the fishman pickups are a huge plus. For this price however there should not be the level of quality control there is. I honestly wouldn't mention the other stuff if there wasn't that small crack in the fingerboard but that is pretty bad. I'll keep this bass for a while as I do like how it plays. Still haven't decided if I can make it a forever bass with mods but we'll see.

upload_2020-10-21_11-36-7.png

upload_2020-10-21_11-36-19.png

upload_2020-10-21_11-36-32.png

upload_2020-10-21_11-36-52.png
 
Seems to me the Ninja and the Atlas are two different beasts: one is a production bass that you buy online, either direct from Legator or from MF (currently 10% off), the other is custom (or at least semi-custom), for which you place an order, and wait for it to be built and shipped.

My concerns with the Ninja would be Legator's reputation for uneven build quality, as well as trying to find an E string that will reach the tuner on that (rather unattractive) 4 + 1 REVERSE headstock. Even if you find a set of strings that are long enough for all strings, your choice of string sets will be pretty limited. I think if you're going to go 36" multiscale, a headless bass will give you more string options.

Yeah I would've gone with the Atlas if I could go back. I'll still make fun with the Legator. Luckily I use dunlops and they make strings that fit. Also Dingwall as of yesterday now sells the dunlop super bright nickels which are my favorite strings.
 
Thanks so much for the in depth take! It seems like it could still be a really great player over-looking those finish flaws. I hope those issues didn't spoil you new bass day too much! You'd expect for any instrument in 2020 that costs $1300 to really not have any types of those problems. I don't care if it's an import or not. I've been an Ibanez guy from day 1 and I've never seen stuff like that from my first starter pack bass to the Premium stuff. Perhaps they can make it right for you though since you took the risk in early adoption but idk.

By the way, I did get to play an Acacia Atlas Pro a while ago. It was actually the one used in this video:
The quality of that instrument was spot on so I think I have to stomach the extra $350 and go with that. Plus, it's supporting these So Cal dudes building stuff right near me which I think its awesome. I do wish the Legator was better quality for the money.
 
Thanks so much for the in depth take! It seems like it could still be a really great player over-looking those finish flaws. I hope those issues didn't spoil you new bass day too much! You'd expect for any instrument in 2020 that costs $1300 to really not have any types of those problems. I don't care if it's an import or not. I've been an Ibanez guy from day 1 and I've never seen stuff like that from my first starter pack bass to the Premium stuff. Perhaps they can make it right for you though since you took the risk in early adoption but idk.

By the way, I did get to play an Acacia Atlas Pro a while ago. It was actually the one used in this video:
The quality of that instrument was spot on so I think I have to stomach the extra $350 and go with that. Plus, it's supporting these So Cal dudes building stuff right near me which I think its awesome. I do wish the Legator was better quality for the money.



Yeah Legator's customer service guy was accommodating. They're giving me a partial refund for it and they do not believe the crack will get worse. They did give me the option to get a new one but I would just rather keep it for now to avoid hassle. They're also sending me the missing gig bag and some shirts for the mix ups. Yeah it seems like Legator is a hit or miss following it's reputation. I'd say Atlas seems worth it especially if you played it before. I believe they're also flexible on pickups and neck wood for their regular Atlas.
 
The scale is apparently 37" and not 36" as I had assumed above. Yikes, that's around 40" from the bridge to the E string tuner. There are certainly strings out there that will fit, it's just another layer of inconvenience and added expense to go through to find one that I would prefer to avoid. I also note that Legator doesn't say which strings they're using.

The other concern I have about Legator is that their website is cagey about who they are. A small team of musicians following their dream who invite us to join them, etc., doesn't really say anything. I actually think I know who owns this company, but I don't want to say who it is because i don't feel like getting into any arguments.

Now that I've thoroughly critiqued this instrument from my armchair, I must admit that I have looked closely at buying it, especially with the 10% offered by MF. I really like that it looks like a custom shop ax. I thought I'd wait to see what new basses will be offered after the New Year. however.
 
The scale is apparently 37" and not 36" as I had assumed above. Yikes, that's around 40" from the bridge to the E string tuner. There are certainly strings out there that will fit, it's just another layer of inconvenience and added expense to go through to find one that I would prefer to avoid. I also note that Legator doesn't say which strings they're using.

The other concern I have about Legator is that their website is cagey about who they are. A small team of musicians following their dream who invite us to join them, etc., doesn't really say anything. I actually think I know who owns this company, but I don't want to say who it is because i don't feel like getting into any arguments.

Now that I've thoroughly critiqued this instrument from my armchair, I must admit that I have looked closely at buying it, especially with the 10% offered by MF. I really like that it looks like a custom shop ax. I thought I'd wait to see what new basses will be offered after the New Year. however.

Yeah I'm lucky my dunlop has strings available through certain vendors as it's my brand of choice. Legator told me their stock strings are dunlop but the guy didn't know which. I'm pretty sure they are the regular stainless steel.

Honestly the thing is a beast and plays great. I wouldn't have mentioned the other minor dings if there was not that tiny sealed crack near the inlay. Also the fishman pickups are somethin else. It's awesome for the price point and room for customizations. However you will take a chance with certain qc. And again their team was accommodating and willing to send me a new bass. Happy hunting!