• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Multi-instrumentalist bassists

With Cale, don't forget viola, a crucial element of the early VU sound, and was prominent on various other sessions like this…


Jeez... I'm blaming that on my COVID. Plus, I forgot piano too, which is weird considering the one time I saw him perform live he played piano.

He opened for Ministry in 1986 and it was in the strangest place outside of Chicago in NW Indiana.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Patrice B
Jeez... I'm blaming that on my COVID. Plus, I forgot piano too, which is weird considering the one time I saw him perform live he played piano.
I think "keyboards" cover it. Cale did some wack viola stuff with Eno and Kevin Ayers as well. One of my greatest lifetime regrets, in terms of missing a performance, was being out of town when he did the entire Paris 1919 album with the UCLA Orchestra at Royce Hall about 10 years ago.
 
While playing a few different, but very similar fretted stringed instruments certainly qualifies to be considered a 'multi instrumentalist'. Maybe those who can add a variety including some of, wind, keys, percussion, or fretless stringed instruments would seem to really take the multi instrumentalist thing to another level. I suppose if you can then also add singing, songwriting, composition, production, mixing and recording, then you reach McCartney (and a few others) level of multiple abilities.
 
I think "keyboards" cover it. Cale did some wack viola stuff with Eno and Kevin Ayers as well. One of my greatest lifetime regrets, in terms of missing a performance, was being out of town when he did the entire Paris 1919 album with the UCLA Orchestra at Royce Hall about 10 years ago.

That's a bummer when that happens, you still regret it.

I saw Brian Wilson perform Pet Sounds with Al Jardine and a ton of other Beach Boys songs at Royce in 2006.

I'm going to see Sunn O))) in the Masonic Lodge at Hollywood Forever Cemetery in a few weeks. I didn't want to have regrets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fialka
I believe Boney James sometimes plays keys on his albums, possibly bass too (though he's been collaborating with Alex Al off and on through the years).

Steve Wilson plays bass on Porcupine Tree's latest album, iirc. He's done it off and on in the past (I think he played bass on "Home Invasion" from the HCE album).
Not many people mention Boney James, or not many other jazz groups or soloists. I would love the opportunity to play bass for a jazz group
 
Maybe I'm biased (I am), but it seems common that when I look up something like who is playing mandolin, flute, sax, or some other random instrument out of the blue on some song it's often the bassist. Keyboardists are another common one, but it still seems bassists are what I see most often.

Some of the big obvious names are McCartney, John Paul Jones, Claypool, Thundercat, Flea, and Marcus Miller. Any other notable ones that come to mind? Am I simply looking at this through a bass players lens, or does it seem bassists tend more towards multi-instrumentalism than others?


I'm guilty of this myself. For me it comes from being a "team-oriented player" I suppose. There were times when we felt like certain songs needed a mandolin. Well, the singer wasn't gonna play anything, the drummer couldn't hit a mandolin, and the guitarist wasn't guaranteed a mando solo so there I was grabbing one and figuring out what we needed. Can I play Mandolin? Enough for the songs we did, but I'm damn sure not a mando player. Then we wanted a Pedal Steel but couldn't find anybody remotely near us and anybody doing remote recordings at the time was well beyond our budget. I finally said just buy me one and I'll figure out the parts we need. And that's just what I did, I learned enough to write some parts for the songs and tracked them. They sound like I actually knew what the hell I was doing. Harmonica at the live show? Yup, threw a neck holder on and figured it out cuz we wanted to play that song. In all those instances my playing the extra instrument had nothing to do with my desire to be a multi-instrumentalist, I just wanted to do what the team needed me to do. Hell, that's what I do as a bass player, I do whatever the song needs me to do. When I was young I wanted to learn how to tap and play 64th-note triplets all day long, but eventually, I learned that the songs sounded much better when I did what they needed me to.

I think we as bass players might just be more mentally suited to do whatever is needed of us to make the song right.
 
I think we as bass players might just be more mentally suited to do whatever is needed of us to make the song right.
I think that is a decent take on why it might be fairly common to see bassists covering other instruments. I know McCartney said pretty much that about why he ended up on bass, no one else wanted to do it so he said I'll do that. I mean, I realize this whole thread and premise is based on biased generalizations, but I think it's fair to say that there's a decent percentage of bassists that fit a role of doing service to the music. Also, straddling melody and rhythm certainly plays a factor as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: semiprohooker