• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD: DIY bass poll, pickguard or bare

To guard, or not to guard. That is the dillema.


  • Total voters
    150
Thanks for all the replies and tips! Wasn't expecting this many reactions when I got home from work :)

The guard would be with a control plate, either chrome or shiny black. I just don't have one yet to try out.
Just a couple of thoughts. As this is a Warmoth bass, only their own control panels match up perfectly with their own scratchplates -like the one you have. If you attempt to use a standard Fender one there will be an ugly gap between them.

Although you have chosen to omit the volume control hole (I imagine because it would have been too close to the lower half of the split coil pickup) any panel you source will still have an empty hole there -unless you fashion one from plastic or metal yourself.

I have also found that black metal control plates never stay black very long. The plating isn't as durable as chrome.

Finally, as someone rightly pointed out previously, you have paid extra for a rear routed body and the split coil has been routed to be visible. I wouldn't go covering any of that up -otherwise you would have been better off buying a standard top routed body -if you were intending on covering up so much of that lovely paint finish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CodyMonster
Pickguards are dumb.

ROFL :D


@HalfManHalfBass

Only 3 holes were needed at the time I ordered as the jack output was moved to the side and the top control on the jazz is very close to the strings IMO which is why I used the three lower holes of the jazz control plate (should I ever fit one).

The PG would be for looks only really.

My preamp will need a 4th hole anyway for all the controls, so I need to drill that somewhere; this could be in line to fit the standard jazz control plate, or more towards the rear and up a bit. Choosing to go with the pickguard has more consequences than just the guard screws.
 
So I'm at the point where I either drill a bunch of holes or keep the top nice and clean.

Which of these two would you pick?
I never buy basses without pickguards, except for my G&L L2000s..and I put pickguards on both of them!
I've seen a few basses that look okay without them, Ibanez comes to mind, but a Jazz bass or Precir.sion without one? I won't even take it down from the wall to try out. Sorry.
(My acoustic basses are the exception, of course.)

By the way, I've been playing for seven or eight years with a pick and never put the slightest mark on any of my pickguards.

Some basses look good with pickguards and no control plates, but the ones with control plates and no pickguards?
No way!
Photo-Collage-1626647320355.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CodyMonster
ROFL :D


@HalfManHalfBass

Only 3 holes were needed at the time I ordered as the jack output was moved to the side and the top control on the jazz is very close to the strings IMO which is why I used the three lower holes of the jazz control plate (should I ever fit one).

The PG would be for looks only really.

My preamp will need a 4th hole anyway for all the controls, so I need to drill that somewhere; this could be in line to fit the standard jazz control plate, or more towards the rear and up a bit. Choosing to go with the pickguard has more consequences than just the guard screws.
If you do go with fitting the Warmoth control plate and an active circuit, be careful to check that the pots all have long enough shafts to go through the increased thickness of the body's top plus the control panel.

Those small pots aren't always long enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CodyMonster