• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD: Fender 75th Anniversary Commemorative Precision Bass

Sep 4, 2010
3,304
2,730
Callicoon, NY
www.jochemvandijk.net
Disclosures
Endorsing: Martin Keith Guitars
Had been looking for a Precision for a while, amidst stock problems and ridiculous 2nd hand prices, and found this one online in July as a MF return/scratch-and-dent with about $400 off the new price. Had been there for a while, not a good sign.

I had other doubts too. Gold hardware is a little tacky to me and it wasn't gonna be a lightweight given the comments online. I like alder, solid fender colors, the roadworn lacquer/nitro finishes and this wasn't any of that. I wondered if it would be different from the much cheaper (at regular prices) Professional II P-bass I had played in a store in Ohio a few months ago, which was built very well, but the tone did not inspire me. As we all know, it's a bit of a gamble with Fenders.

I gave it a shot, knowing it could be returned. First unpacking wasn't good: close to unplayable and sounded as dead as a doornail. Right, that's why it was so much cheaper. But on the other hand, the bodywood looked really good (2 piece ash with beautiful figuring) and the neck felt solid, with very well dressed frets. This felt and looked very well built, unlike the 2 lightweight AVRI basses I used to own, which either felt slapped together with woods so soft or insufficiently dried the strap buttons fell out within 2 weeks, or just didnt have the bottom to the tone you want from a Pbass, and didn't balance great.

Comes out the bass came with deadbeat roundwounds, and a recessed pickup combined with a monstrous backbow to the chunky neck. A substantial trussrod adjustment and setup with a new set of Labella LTFs later and boy what a transformation. This is a really good Pbass: even across all the strings, the right combination of warmth, thump and kick all across the fretboard-really what you (or at least, I) want from a Pbass. The more I play it the better it gets. Not even the dreaded dead spot around the d on the g string.

The weight is 9.8 lbs which is not super comfy, but just acceptable, however the balance on a strap is perfect. (I've never played a lightweight Pbass that sounded like a good Pbass anyway-see AVRI comments above).

I really believe they do pick better pieces of wood for this series - a bit 70-ties style old school with the relatively heavy ash body but man - what a great classic P-bass tone. And the neck is now super stable, no ski jump at all - that is a good piece of maple too. A joy to play Jamerson, reggae, soul, jazz or anything else rootsy, really. Some substantial playing time and it will shake loose the tone even more, easily bettering my lamented 76 Mocha that I sold years ago.

I lucked out.

Pbass.jpg
 
Congrats for your acquisition!

It is very nice piece of gear. There is one with similar dent-return policy with few 100$ discount at local store. I am juggling between this one and the Am Pro 2. It is hard to tell because they dont have a Pro 2 in stock to make comparison.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fishdreams
Congrats for your acquisition!

It is very nice piece of gear. There is one with similar dent-return policy with few 100$ discount at local store. I am juggling between this one and the Am Pro 2. It is hard to tell because they dont have a Pro 2 in stock to make comparison.
Thank you! As for comparison: there was nothing wrong with the Pro II i played in that store; i'd say build quality was about the same. It sounded good, and especially good in the low end. Very good allround bass with the tone on the modern side, great with roundwounds. My commerative bass has much more of a classic vibe in tone and appearance that just screams for flatwounds. It is just what you are looking for i guess-i love the pbass for the trad stuff, where i have my Martin Keiths for a more outspoken and refined expressiveness, so to speak.

I actually have been impressed with the build quality of both. If this kind of build consistency is the new Fender, it is a big step up imo.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: VitoMB
Thank you! As for comparison: there was nothing wrong with the Pro II i played in that store; i'd say build quality was about the same. It sounded good, and especially good in the low end. Very good allround bass with the tone on the modern side, great with roundwounds. My commerative bass has much more of a classic vibe in tone and appearance that just screams for flatwounds. It is just what you are looking for i guess-i love the pbass for the trad stuff, where i have my Martin Keiths for a more outspoken and refined expressiveness, so to speak.

I actually have been impressed with the build quality of both. If this kind of build consistency is the new Fender, it is a big step up imo.

Thanks for all details. It will certainly help me to make decision. Have you noticed a difference in weight ? I think that the Am Pro 2 is very lightweight. I was wondering if it is similar to the 75th Commemorative.
 
  • Like
Reactions: fishdreams
Thanks for all details. It will certainly help me to make decision. Have you noticed a difference in weight ? I think that the Am Pro 2 is very lightweight. I was wondering if it is similar to the 75th Commemorative.
I remember the Pro II as being a bit lighter in weight. They are mostly alder I think. Sweetwater has a bunch in stock with listed weights, they are all under 9lbs. The Commemoratives I've seen were listed between 9.4 and over 10lbs. Mine is 9.8 lbs

I happen to be partial to maple necks for P-basses, but if rosewood is your thing, the Pro-II is the only option.

After all I'm glad I got mine. It gives me what i want from a P-bass, which is a bit like owning a vintage car - special and fun for certain things, next to the daily driver which is my Martin Keith.

If I were to get one workhorse bass to cover any musical scenario (the daily driver) I probably would have opted for the Professional II. Just YMMV etc.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: VitoMB
I'm looking for information on how many of the 75th Anniversary Commemorative Precision Basses were made. If it is a limited edition, shouldn't there be some way to tell them apart? Like, "this is number 57 of 2000" or something like that.
 
The following thread includes a post from someone who communicated with Fender and was told there were 1100 copies of both the J and the P. There doesn't appear to be any obvious indication on my P as to what edition# it might be. Perhaps the serial number has a clue?

 
Last edited:
The following thread includes a post from someone who communicated with Fender and was told there were 1100 copies of both the J and the P. There doesn't appear to be any obvious indication on my P as to what edition# it might be. Perhaps the serial number has a clue?

I started collecting em
 

Attachments

  • Basses.jpg
    Basses.jpg
    1.1 MB · Views: 15