• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

New GassieBall taste test: soundclip challenge inside!

I've been doing a lot of SX modding recently. My personal favorite bass tonewise is my Lakland DJ4, but I've been enjoying short scales so much, that I've been trying to emulate the Lakland with my SJB75 short scale SX Jazz. Along the way, I got a couple of other shorties for fun.

Here is a quickly recorded soundclip of six basses. In no particular order listed here, they are

Fender Mustang stock pickups
SX SJB75 ash short scale jazz with Nordstrand NJ4's
Squier Bronco with DiMarzio ProTrack
SX SJB75 alder short scale jazz with Dimarzio Model J's
Lakland DJ4 (full scale)
SX SPB57 short scale with Nordstand NP4

Please don't get all scientific on me about recording levels, technique (mine sucks), whether or not a bat can tell the difference, etc. This is just for fun and I recorded it in my cold basement with slightly stiff fingers in one take (per bass). :hiding: :D

I overdubbed me speaking the numbers 1-6 into the MP3 file if you guys want to try to guess. If the bass is a jazz, both pickups are on full and tone is wide open. My fingers are playing at a position between both pickups. If the bass is a P, the pickup is on full and the tone is wide open and I'm playing perhaps an inch toward the bridge from the pickup. The bass goes straight into a PreSonus FirePod into Garageband on a Mac with no effects, compression, etc.

So, what do you think of the tones and which is which? Do you think short scales really sound that floppy with too much fundamental emphasis (like what many people say)?

Thanks for listening to the Invalid Link Removed!!!
 
I like 1, 2 and 6 the best. I just bought a Bronco and Mustang in the last few weeks and am really digging the shortscales lately. I can play either scale, but IMHO, why make it harder than it has to be if you can achieve the tones you want with a smaller and lighter bass guitar.
 
The DJ has the Lakland Pickups. I think it's the sweetest sounding Jazz I've owned. I spent a bit of time trying to make a Squire sound like my Lakland, but it never worked out. The ash SX, however, when fitted with NJ4's comes rather close to the tone I'm looking for.
 
he he definitely liked #3 the full scale most.
I was a little disappointed as I woped I'd pick a short scale!
But my second and third picks were the sx's with the Nordstrands!
I don't have an SX short yet and I'm using this challenge to help me shop THANK YOU!
Now to listen again,now that I know which is which...
 
hmmm after listening more and adjusting volume a little to compensate for variations in level,I still have to say I like the SX's over the Fenders,but the Lakland #1 overall.
The #2 (Dimarzio SX jazz) sounds better if you turn it up a bit.At first I thought "thin/flat" but now I'd say "round/compressed".
Totally humble observation,anybody else get same feeling?