I'm still anxiously awaiting my replacement preamp from Dean, so no real update as of yet. I did take a look at the pots and jack though and decided that even though Dean's sending me a complete assembly, I'm going to cut and solder in just the preamp (with a little liquid electrical tape on the connections to prevent anything from getting crossed in the future). The knobs on my guitar appear to be black anodized aluminum and perfect, but they're not held on with set screws, so I'm guessing they're glued on. I'd rather spend an hour soldering than have to worry about getting the knobs off and back on again without ruining anything. Then I'll just take the spare pots and jack and toss them in a box for future use.
Now as far as the preamp goes, the original was just stuffed into the wiring cavity and not secured to anything, which might have been part of the problem. It looks like it has an adhesive backing that was never peeled, like it could have been secured to the inside of the cover. What should I do with the new one? Should I leave it loose, or secure it to the cover to keep it from moving?