• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

P Bass Original or Partsacaster?

View attachment 4971971 View attachment 4971973 View attachment 4971974 View attachment 4971976 View attachment 4971978

Went to see this bass today. But after inspection I walked away.


I had some doubts over its authenticity so would welcome some thoughts on what everyone else thinks here.

It was owned by a guy who was known in his day to build up guitars. He also had a jazz of the same period but had been badly refinished (pictures next to each other).
This P bass body did have some age-related discolouring, but it just didn't feel like it all add up to me.

Am I wrong here? Have I walked away from a good buy?

It looks more likely made by Fender, in Maui Blue, than not.

All P basses are parts basses, since 1951, whether they have that $2.00 (in today's dollar) waterslide decal or not. If we don't know the asking price there's no possibility to determine what kind of deal it is, even if it were made by Fender, pre-CBS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
View attachment 4971971 View attachment 4971973 View attachment 4971974 View attachment 4971976 View attachment 4971978

Went to see this bass today. But after inspection I walked away.


I had some doubts over its authenticity so would welcome some thoughts on what everyone else thinks here.

It was owned by a guy who was known in his day to build up guitars. He also had a jazz of the same period but had been badly refinished (pictures next to each other).
This P bass body did have some age-related discolouring, but it just didn't feel like it all add up to me.

Am I wrong here? Have I walked away from a good buy?
Sweet Jeebus. That's a Maui Blue Precision…and Jazz!! I'd be trading in my '75 in a heartbeat if it plays nice!!
 
Sweet Jeebus. That's a Maui Blue Precision…and Jazz!! I'd be trading in my '75 in a heartbeat if it plays nice!!

The Jazz is a repaint. Hard to tell from the photo but it's a very light blue (different to the P) with paint runs. Generally shoddy job but likely done a while ago.

I'm a Jazz fan so the J is what I went to see but was majorly disappointed. The P bass was just for comparison but actually ended up liking it until I realised the asking price.

With the Jazz being painted (and no photos of neck pocket/pots/pickup stamps) I'm not sure if that's priced right either.

Little dealer so perhaps just priced at the late mint original 70s models they believed they had. I might make an offer with all this information in mind but where is fair to pitch it for either or both?!
 
The Jazz is a repaint. Hard to tell from the photo but it's a very light blue (different to the P) with paint runs. Generally shoddy job but likely done a while ago.

I'm a Jazz fan so the J is what I went to see but was majorly disappointed. The P bass was just for comparison but actually ended up liking it until I realised the asking price.

With the Jazz being painted (and no photos of neck pocket/pots/pickup stamps) I'm not sure if that's priced right either.

Little dealer so perhaps just priced at the late mint original 70s models they believed they had. I might make an offer with all this information in mind but where is fair to pitch it for either or both?!
I wouldn't have the foggiest clue as to what they'd be worth. I base the value of an instrument (to me) purely on how it appeals to me personally. So if that Jazz felt and played amazing (to me) I'd factor in getting it refinished (in Maui Blue of course because it's my favourite colour) and go from there.