• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass Paul Chambers - jeez - how good was this guy?

Circumstances have left me with Miles Davis albums to practice with until I get myself reorganized. Meanwhile, I am listening to Miles' albums from the late '50s and realizing just how good Paul Chambers is/was. So much warm tone that a more casual listener could relate to while the horns are breaking new ground at the other end of the sonic spectrum. Definitely one of the top bassists ever, and as concerns my own style on upright - the guy I'd like to emulate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Paul New
It's funny, most people can't distinguish between spectacular playing, and mediocre playing, outside of a solo. They just know which song grooves better.

And as a novice, I can't always put my finger on EXACTLY what someone (like PC) is doing differently. But when I am listening to something on NPR, I'll stop and say "that bassist is hot!" And it's subtle (at least to someone like me). Something about the tone or the note placement, or some subtle note selection, nothing inherently drastic. But the overall effect is huge, and I notice. And when the announcer comes back on. And of course the bassist is Paul Chambers, or Red Mitchell, or some other great...
 
P.C. was a monster playing pizz or arco. I think it was the mans subtlety that made him swing like that. If you listen carefully he threw down lots of ghost notes, pushed and pulled the beat, played a lot of tone colour and would imply all sorts of things in behind the tunes that made them really work.
He really grabbed my heart the instant I heard him.
 
If you get a chance try to see Miles Davis Birth of the Cool, the documentary film. PC is all over the soundtrack and it's great to hear him on those big movie theater speakers. I take a contrarian view actually. He's one of my heros - imagine if he didn't drink and drug himself into an early death - but I find his soloing kind of formulaic and banal. What he does amazingly well is make every track he plays on bouyant and alive, which is actually a much harder and bigger thing to do than play a fancy solo. Sure wish I could have seen him play. I've worked with guys who played with him and apparently he was a very humble and gentle man.
 
I was a big fan of Wes Montgomery and Wynton Kelly and PC was their preferred bassist. I loved learning all the Motown and R&B parts and those bassist were terrific, but Paul Chambers was my idol. There was something about his ensemble playing I really loved, not just his incredible "chops".
 
  • Like
Reactions: lurk