• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Pick or Pluck

DubDubs said:
Pluck. I can't stand using a pick. I'd say start out plucking when you start to discover what kind of sounds you like try using a pick, see if you like it better.
Well, I'd agree, but I'm primarily a pick player now cuz I wanted all my notes to sound like they were being slapped, except i wouldn't have all the brightness. I DID start out on fingers, and then after I knew what type of rock i liked (metal, death metal, punk, all types), I knew that pick was the way to go for an attack. the only time i want to use fingers now is unless I'm playing something that really needs to sound tender, or if i feel like doing the whole funk/RnB/slap deal.

all In all, if you think playing with fingers makes a difference between a pick, your only partially right. The other half of the deal (that stands out more) is what sound your dialing into your preamp on your rig, and how your utilizing the pickups on your bass.
 
Starting out you should play with your fingers for a majority of the time. Playing fingerstyle allows you to do different right hand techniques without worrying about a pesky piece of plastic in your hand. As you progress( and get an amp if you don't have one already, which makes fingerstyle sound A LOT better compared to just playing without an amp) you can decide what technique to use primarily.

You should use both techniques though, at least in an experimental format. I believe the ideal bassist should be adept at both fingerstyle and pick, for both have their advantages. Fingerstyle is great for groove while pick is better for fast black metal-type lines.
 
embellisher said:
learn both techniques. they both have their place, and are valuable.

Word. Great advice. I usually play fingerstyle with bands with clean guitars but a pick is necessary with any kind of distorted guitar bands just to cut through. As most of you know, friggin guitarists have to turn up louder than hell most of the time! :bassist: