• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

picking tone without the pick

I used a pick for a couple of years also. My opinion: I get a harsht trebley/high, almost a scraping sound just never fit. even after eq'n and I could never seem to completly play any tune with out handing off the pick to my guitar player and saying "It yours". On the other hand,,, I'm an old timer playing Classic Rock. Yea I konw lots of bass players play rock with a pick and some are great. I must of just been too shy with the pick and never got over it. Anyway It's so natural now with the getty lee style pick'n that I second the motion that it makes bass playing way more fun. :bassist: (my vote: plectrom=Lead guirtar)
 
I use something quite similar, a pluck that is a simultaneous middle finger upstroke and index finger downstroke (on the nail) gives a warm yet bright sound, works well, and expands the variety of tones at disposal.

Personally, I'd give anything a go, nobody's every generated new and interesting tecnique by doing exactly what everyone else has done for the last 50 years!

The bass can generate quite a spectrum of textural sounds, it's half the fun of playing... that and subverting the music... gawd bless it:) john
 
dreamer25 said:
First off, why use a pick to begin with when you have five on your right hand? Even if you dont like a type of music listen to or watch the bass player and his/her technique. My best suggestion is jazz players like Victor Wooten. That man can make you cry without saying a word. Look him up and listen to his solos. Picks i think slow you down, you can downward stroke the strings with your nails to make chords.

Ooh and one last thing, picks do NOT help you play faster. I used to play with one until i came across a Victor Wooten video of a solo and now i can play faster without one.

I used to never play a pick, then I came across some footage of John Entwistle.

The point here is that the pick is used for an aggresive sound with more bite to it. There is absolutely nothing wrong with using a pick it makes you no less of a bassist in any way. I mean look at Bill Wyman.
 
I hate picks. The scratchy sound really annoys me. I use my finger nail like geddy has been described. I can flamenco pick faster than most people can with a pick.(and sounds nicer in my opinion). So I prefer my finger when I'm looking for a slightly harsher sound that's not too harsh. I very my playing for what's needed.