• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Poll: Rate my Tone

What would you Honestly Rate My Tone?

  • Novice Tone (don't like it)

    Votes: 4 2.6%
  • Intermediate Tone (its good)

    Votes: 11 7.1%
  • Semi Professional Tone (it's very good)

    Votes: 34 21.9%
  • Professional Tone (it's Very great)

    Votes: 106 68.4%

  • Total voters
    155
So he's fishing for compliments...I don't care. His tone is awesome. His playing is awesome. I'm sorry to hear about your finger, but you've shown the effects of dedication to your craft. You sound great.


But how the hell are you guys set up!?! You're in a different country than the drummer and you're all lined up in this awkward way. I feel for you there man. That can't be an easy way to play.
 
I voted Pro. Love your playing, and the tone. I believe some of the tone is in your style, touch, and desire to get that tone. I think there are at least 5000 tones in any Fodera, although I can't ever get that tone, for me. But I'll bet that bass, in my hands, after 10 seconds of knob turning, can sound like John Wetton.
 
So he's fishing for compliments...I don't care. His tone is awesome. His playing is awesome. I'm sorry to hear about your finger, but you've shown the effects of dedication to your craft. You sound great.


But how the hell are you guys set up!?! You're in a different country than the drummer and you're all lined up in this awkward way. I feel for you there man. That can't be an easy way to play.

That's what happens when you play in a church that was not set up for a band.
 
Nice playing but I don't understand the association tone = playing skills or professionalism ... uh what's the deal?
Ehm...
That's my whole point. I asked everyone to "rate my tone" but most read "rate my solo" I assure you guys while all the compliments are nice that I really want to get opinions on the tone. The way I pluck the notes....if I should have added more treble or bass etc.....That's where I've been kinda of unsure on. I'm confident in my gifting. Just not 100% with my hear tone or sound.
 
"I agree a bit more treble and you've got the perfect tone. I'd recommend also a slightly harder pluck."

That seems about right.

Hat's off to you, sir, for your obvious dedication and for not letting your injury prevent you from playing. The results of your hard work are truly an inspiration. Keep on!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
OK, there is your answer. It doesn't matter what any of us think, because it is "your" tone, not ours.
True but I thought it would be fun to see what everyone else thought. It lets me know whether I'm on track or not. Jeeze what ever happened to the good days of helping your fellow bassist out without everyone being so judgmental. Believe it or not no good bass player on this earth became good all by him/herself. They listen to or was taught things by other players. I posted this video just for that purpose not to upset anyone or make them feel like I'm fishing for compliments. Again if 10 out of 10 people tell me that my tone suck then I don't believe I should have the attitude "it's my tone and that's all that matters." That's 20 ears against my 2. We are all human and humans help humans grow whether learning from others good deeds or mistakes (their wisdom) or your good deeds or own mistakes (your wisdom). Afterall we all have but to think back to our own childhoods. Don't know anyone who taught themselves their own native language or taught their own self in high school or college. How can we teach ourselves music which is basically another language?

Moral of the story...it's always good to get other people opinions whether negative or positive. I heard a wise man once say that people are like a batteries in your car.....everyone has a positive and a negative. You need both to start that car. As aweful as it sounds I wouldn't be who I am today without cutting one my fingers off. Not to mention a lot more I could mention. Just my thoughts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr. Cheese
ATL represent! Great city. My sister-in-law lives in Stone Mountain (she used to live in ATL) and I've been down there a number of times.

Anyway, back to your question... I voted "Pro tone." Man that sounded great! Your tone (and playing - even though you didn't ask for that feedback) sound on point to me. The only thing I would suggest is a bit more presence (mids, attack, dirt, whatever you want to call it). The second solo seemed to have more presence than the first - perhaps just a mixing issue. Regardless, you and your band killed that tune.

Now how is it that I have all of my digits intact and I can't even play 1/4 as good as you? :D
Lol thanks sir
 
This is my take on it. Every instrument has certain sweet spots on it. On my upright the low G, Low A on the E string, the F on the D string, the Bb on both the A and G strings, and Eb on the A string all have a phenomenal growl to them. It really "grinds" there against the keyboard. So, as I've gained experience with the instrument, I know to really milk those notes when they pop up in my bass lines.

If I have a choice of which "A" to use, I'll go with the A on the low E string if I can because of the grind there. Also, there are certain notes where the way I place my fingertip pads (on an angle) on the keyboard creates a particular tone. It's only on certain notes, and again, I know to milk those notes. It sort of comes unconsciously after you've bonded with the instrument for a while. Along with this is vibrato. I know where to do it on various notes for maximum effect, and how to sort of bend the strings on certain notes to create a really unique tone as i play a run.

Last of all -- attack and release of notes creates a fluidity in bass lines. I often have to take the written notes on some songs, or patterns I create myself, and then figure out the best way to hammer on and pull off various notes to give me time to get from one note to another or embed "groove" into the bassline. Also, to create a flow in the bassline so it doesn't sound stumbly or introduce unwanted string noise. I think this influences the other aspects of tone, to create a unique sound in your fingers.

I think it's one reason musicians love to stay with a particular instrument. Jaco's fender jazz, Marcus Millers Blonde jazz, Sheehan's double precision pickup.

Complementing this is amplification equipment. After a while you get to know the kind of tone you want that amplifies or complements the natural tone on the instrument and its sweet spots. So you know the balance of treble, bass and mids that you need. I can get a similar tone on a wide variety of amps and cabs. The biggest impediment is how complicated the manufacturer has made the controls. I have a Peavey Pro Bass 500 and it has such detailed controls I have a hard time finding the tone I want. Perhaps that's why they don't make them anymore. See below:

Peavey Pro Bass 500 - Yahoo Image Search Results

But give me a relatively simple bass amplifier, I can make it sound the way I want. The room you are in influences the tone as well, and some rooms are just boomy. But in decent acoustics, the tone from the amp for me, is driven more by the complexity of the eq and gain controls on the instrument, not the amplifier itself. Complex controls make it harder to find good tone fast.

Food for thought
 
So he's fishing for compliments...I don't care. His tone is awesome. His playing is awesome. I'm sorry to hear about your finger, but you've shown the effects of dedication to your craft. You sound great.


But how the hell are you guys set up!?! You're in a different country than the drummer and you're all lined up in this awkward way. I feel for you there man. That can't be an easy way to play.
Yeah I know we were at the mercy of the minister of music of that church he demanded that's the way he wanted it.
 
My impression FWIW is that for some reason - eq settings ? - room issues ? - recorder limitations ? - the low end notes don't sound like they come from the same instrument - all the upper and mid register playing sounds very organic and seamless - whereas the lower register notes don't have that same sense of cohesiveness . To me they seem to come from out of left field and lack the same tone as the rest . I hope this makes some sense and apologize for being unable to express myself better . Kelly