• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Schecter Diamond series vs MIM Fender?

Which bass for pop punk/emo rock?

  • Schecter Diamond P

    Votes: 74 32.3%

  • MIM Fender P

    Votes: 114 49.8%

  • MIM Fender J

    Votes: 41 17.9%
  • Total voters
    229
U

Upecko

Nov 5, 2012
2
0
Phoenix, AZ
#1
First post here.
Anyway, just started playing bass for a pop punk band and I'm going out to buy a new bass this week. I work at a music store so I can get a GREAT discount on Schecters and an okay discount on Fenders. The thing is, I'm normally a guitarist so I want your guys's input. What are your thoughts on a Schecter diamond P bass vs. say a MIM Fender as far as tone, build quality, etc.? The Schecter would be a lot cheaper than the Fender for me and I need a bass for our shows coming up this month. Have any of you had experience with the Diamond series P?

If I were to go Fender I don't know if I would pick a J or P...so there lies another factor.

Thanks in advance.
 
#2
Well you can't go wrong with a Fender P. It's a fantastic bass sound that just plain works. That being said, I'd vote for the Schecter (hint: maybe add a poll to this thread). I say this, even though I haven't played one, because it seems like a better purchase. Not only is there the standard P pickup, but the bridge pickup can be a single coil, like a J pickup, or a humbucker. That in and of itself is a selling point, in my opinion. The main reason the Diamond P initially caught my eye is being offered as a 5er. Not sure if that sways your opinion.

Play both unplugged side by side (with a strap) and choose which is more comfortable. Then, plug them in and let your ears decide.

Good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: .BumeStik.
#3
Choose the one that feels best. I've never played Schecter P-bass but i just got Schecter Hellraiser 5 bass and i have been playing various Schecter guitars. I think that they are good (at least every one that i have played so far...) I'm quite sure that both will do the job so pick up the one you like.
 
#5
MTelinkangas said:
Choose the one that feels best. I've never played Schecter P-bass but i just got Schecter Hellraiser 5 bass and i have been playing various Schecter guitars. I think that they are good (at least every one that i have played so far...) I'm quite sure that both will do the job so pick up the one you like.
Click to expand...

This. How it sounds and how it plays are crucial. If you prefer the one with a better discount that's great - but get the one you connect with best if possible.
The bass, amp and cab and effects if any are essential factors in getting where you want tonally, experiment with as many of those factors as you can to get to where you want. If you don't have a precise tone in mind, so much the better - you'll need to work with the overall sound of the band to get the best balance as I understand it.

On a separate note what exactly is pop punk? It sounds like classical bluegrass in terms of internal conflict?? I don't know how to phrase it clearly. Is this broadly accurate?: https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pop_punk surely it's pop rock???
 
#6
I had the 5 string version and except for a couple of "design" issues (weight, 35" scale and 5 in line headstock none of which are a problem with the 4 string version) it was one of the best playing and sounding non-Fender P bass I ever owned and this is comparing it to a Fender Am. Dlx P Bass, so I know of which I speak.

The Schecter is a Strong sounding Bass:

Check out "Time It Comes" & "Love Crashing Down"
Link Removed (played mostly on the B string)




Me with the Fender.....
I don't have any pictures of me with my Schecter, but here is a picture I took of it (proof I had one)
 

Attachments

  • Dave@CH.jpg
    [email protected]
    32.1 KB · Views: 296
  • P-5-Body-Fnt.jpg
    P-5-Body-Fnt.jpg
    40.4 KB · Views: 312
#8
As long as it has a P pickup, I think you're good. Like others have said, try em all and pick the one that plays/sounds best to you. And that's not to say that you can't use a J for pop punk/emo. The bassist for the Sidekicks uses a J iirc. But to me, when I think of pop punk and emo, I think of bands like Blink-182, Green Day, Jawbreaker, Cap'n Jazz, Sunny Day Real Estate, and the like, all of whom have bassists who use P's, and all of whom have nice, chunky bass tones. In fact, Fender just put out a signature model for the bassist of SDRE.
 
#10
Every schecter i've played has been good. Of course there's lots of higher end makers but for the price schecters are high quality. I've played mainly guitar so my preferences are from guitars and just two hellraiser basses but i don't think that their basses are worse than their guitars.
 
#15
Without playing each individual bass, I'd have to suggest the MIM Fender, especially if it's a Fender Special Run with the better body wood.

If that doesn't work out, how about a good Fender at a Schecter price? Squier Classic Vibe...
 
#20
I played the MIM J 5-string in a SA store recently and was impressed, both with how it felt but also with the electronics built-in. Don't know about the P but if it has same electronics you will have a wide choice of different sounds and tones from the bass itself. The J was priced around $800.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back