I just love the range of responses! (It's what keeps me coming back: Variety!) I'm glad the OP chose a luthier, in the end, as it seemed to be the best solution in this case.
I would welcome the luxury of "buying new" but am at a point in my life (a LOT closer to the end than the beginning) that used is usually the path I choose. With a "pre-owned" bass, or a pre-owned just-about-anything, you get a bunch of benefits: the bugs are worked out, the previous owner can, or at least should, let you know the history, the cost is much lower, and you've kept something out of the landfill. Rescue a bass today! Oh, and you almost always get a GREAT story out of hunting for, finding and revitalizing a used bass, instead of, "Yeah, the guy at the store handed it to me. Then, I paid for it."
(I should edit my profile and add "used" in front of everything I own!)