• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Switching To Flatwounds On P-Bass?

scottrolf

scottrolf

Jul 13, 2011
367
348
Bandon, OR
#1
Five of the six basses I own all have round wounds with the exception of my Fender Jaco signature J fretless which has the flats. Love it BTW.

I am tempted to convert my current production Am Std P-bass to flats but don't really know what I'm in store for tone-wise. I love the tone of the flats on the Jaco but sometimes would like that same tone with a fretted bass. Will the pickups on my P react well with flats or are they more designed for rounds?

Thanks,
 
#3
scottrolf said:
Five of the six basses I own all have round wounds with the exception of my Fender Jaco signature J fretless which has the flats. Love it BTW.

I am tempted to convert my current production Am Std P-bass to flats but don't really know what I'm in store for tone-wise. I love the tone of the flats on the Jaco but sometimes would like that same tone with a fretted bass. Will the pickups on my P react well with flats or are they more designed for rounds?

Thanks,
Click to expand...
Roundwound strings didn't exist when the P bass and its pickup were designed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Darren Saw, bass08053, Aqualung60 and 7 others
#5
There are a few midpoints you can also try. Pressure wounds are just a little flatter than round. Then ground wound and half rounds get closer to flat. Tape wounds are round strings with a thin tape over them that make them feel flat. You'll see lots of fans of various types. My preference is D'Addario Chromes and that is what is on my P currently. I've got a slightly hot pickup, and I find myself rolling back the volume just a bit from full gets me a very nice sound. No pickup/string/output complications. Jump on in :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ken J, nerkoids, lermgalieu and 2 others
#7
When I got my AS Precision I wanted to put flats on it straight away, and I had been using roundwound strings since 1987 & now I doubt I'll ever put roundwounds on my Precision. The only gripe I had was that I couldn't get the Fender 9050 flats in 45-105 gauge (my favorite), but Dunlop do a 45-105 set & there not bad at all.
 
#8
Shawn Luckman said:
When I got my AS Precision I wanted to put flats on it straight away, and I had been using roundwound strings since 1987 & now I doubt I'll ever put roundwounds on my Precision. The only gripe I had was that I couldn't get the Fender 9050 flats in 45-105 gauge (my favorite), but Dunlop do a 45-105 set & there not bad at all.
Click to expand...
Fender makes a 9050CL Custom Light which are .045 - .105.
 
#10
IronLung1986 said:
It's a popular thing to do. I've tried chromes and half-flats, and for me it takes away too much of the clarity and articulation. I like some harmonic hair on the sound of my P, so I stick with rounds.
Click to expand...
This.

I like a P with LaBellas. That strong fundamental is just killer. But there is a lot of tonal information that is missing when rocking flats that makes them limiting for certain styles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: scottrolf, bobyoung53 and 60bass
#12
Flats on a P bass!!?? I don't think it's been done. Try it and report back to us!

JK. In all seriousness, round wound bass strings weren't around when the P bass was created, so the more appropriate question is "how will rounds react with the pick up?". They used to all have flats. And yes, it's a very nice sound, closer to the upright bass it was designed to emulate.
 
#14
While P pickup designs have changed over the years, I think sounds may differ more between different types of flats. You may want to try a few different ones before you find one you like on your P... it's fun, I'm just trying Labellas on my P (odly enough, I think this is the first time I'm trying them on a P, heh)
 
#15
I bought my Lull PJ5 with DR strings on it and the sound was great. I put GHS Precision flats on it and IMO the sound improved significantly.

Sometimes I want a little more twang and I play my Lakland but there's something about a P with flats that makes me smile.

It might not be everyone's cup of tea but if you own a Precision of any type you owe it to yourself to try it with a set of flats.
 
#18
I've put flats on all my basses and I'll say that I love the Tomastik Flats, and had bought them because I thought I'd prefer the lower string tension, but I soon discovered that I really really love the much less expensive DiMarzio Chromes. The string tension is indeed higher than that Tomstiks, but I like how it gives me a tighter response. Flatwounds ona P-Bass is just fantastic.
 
  • Like
Reactions: daveman50

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back