For the record-- the buzz DID turn out to be from the tailpiece. I ended up taking the bass in to the shop, and we figured out that the tailpiece wire was pulling out of the clamp thing that holds it together. It's kinda crazy to see how much something like that affects your overall sound-- I hadn't really noticed a difference, but when I pulled out old Plywood Polly the backup bass, it was like twice as loud as my main bass. It was probably about time for me to have my setup re-done-- soundpost, bridge,etc., but dang, apparently your tailpiece wire plays as big a part as anything.