• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

The female version of SMV would be

Meshell Ndegeocello
Debra Killings
Rhonda Smith

I would replace Debra Killings with the chick in that old SWR factory youtube clip from the early 90's. I don't know who she was but she was killin' it like Rhonda or Meshell. Funky as hell!

Go to 2:36 in the clip. Anyone know who she is? Is the SWR guy a member here?
 
Tal Wilkenfeld
Divinity Roxx - swappable with M'Shell or Debra or Rhonda
Esperanza

@DWBass - I have the proofs of all the photo's from that day in a box in my office. I didn't know a video existed thank you for the find.
 
Tal's not funky enough..nor is she black. Tal is more of a fusion/rock player. The girls below are funky AND jazzy. Remember SMV specialize mostly in something different. Tones are different, techniques are different, etc etc...so with that being said.

I would go with
Meshell or Rhonda in Victor's place
Nik West-would obviously be in Marcus's place
Esperanza-of course would be Stanley's place
 
Teja' Lanise(Musiq Soulchild) because she's got that thick urban 5 string groove that a lot of the modern Gospel cats have.

Debra Killings(Outkast, TLC, solo) becase she has the funk, soul, jazz, RnB, rock thing down plus she's a great vocalist, AND she plays a 6 too.

Esperanza Spaulding because she's Esperanza Spaulding dammit!!....NUFF SAID!

I think the edge that an all female bass supergroup would have is that they are all in this group pretty awesome vocalists....SMV have all dabbled in singing but...
 
Kim Clarke has got to be in the list. She's a pioneer for all the others listed.

kim_clarke2004_1.jpg




Mine would be:

Kim Clarke
Meshell
Rhonda Smith


Esperanza is awesome but I don't think she fits the vibe of SMV.
 
Since my first listening of Defunkt in the early 90's I've been a huge fan. Would have loved to meet her. Congrats.
I hung out with TB member pyrohr, and he's the one who took me to this open mic jam. He knows her well among many other killin' musicians! Shawn (Epifani) plays bass for the house band and I got to meet him as well as Barry Johnson who's played for Chic and some Fusion and R&B artists back in the day. He's the brother of Reggie Vel Johnson of Family Matters fame.

Anyway, sorry for the hijack. Just had to get it out.
 

Latest posts