• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Troy

Benjamin Strange

Commercial User
Dec 25, 2002
9,737
310
49
New Orleans, LA
www.ufodeathcult.com
Disclosures
Owner / Tech: Strange Guitarworks
What a terrible, terrible, terrible movie. Ugh. 3 hours of complete utter garbage. I highly recommend staying home and practicing instead.

Where do I begin? First, I should say that this was a movie inspired by, rather than based on, the Illiad. They took serious artistic liscence with this. Homer is rolling in his grave. Love interests were introduced, plot twists, etc... not that the plot "twists" made any sense, anyway. The script was nothing but a bunch of cliche nonsense strung together; there wasn't a single normal conversation through out the whole movie. No character development, just a parade of fools saying stupid things with no emotion whatsoever.

This was a seriously big budget movie, too. $200 million dollars, and I can't begin to imagine where all that money went. It really didn't even look very good. The battle scenes were muddled and indistict, and the sets were rather plain. The costumes were good, but costumes don't cost $200 million. I sure hope they don't recoup that obscene amount of money. I felt like they wasted mine.

When we finally got to the end, almost everybody in the theater (about 1000 people) booed. It was really that bad. A 3 hour movie is alot to take in all at once, but a really bad 3 hour movie is sheer torture. Do yourself a favor and avoid this one.

Unless you want to see Brad Pitt and Orlando Bloom half naked. There's plenty of that going on in this one. :rolleyes:
 
MJ5150 said:
Thank you for the review. I am fascinated with this period of human history, so I may see it anyway. At least now I know not to expect much.

-Mike


Given the review, it would probably be a better idea to rent. Or, I'm sure there's some old 60's version of the Illiad.

This kind of reminds me of the Liz Taylor "Cleopatra" debacle back in the early 60's (date right?).

I'm curious, why kind of "artistic licenses" did they take? When I saw Brad Pitt in the listings, I had a feeling they'd try to make it into a "Good v. Bad w/ a moral at the end" movie, which it isn't at all...everyone in the story's a sleaze bag, except for maybe Hector.
 
Against Will said:
I'm curious, why kind of "artistic licenses" did they take? When I saw Brad Pitt in the listings, I had a feeling they'd try to make it into a "Good v. Bad w/ a moral at the end" movie, which it isn't at all...everyone in the story's a sleaze bag, except for maybe Hector.

Well, they introduced several love interests that I don't remember being in the book. (one of which the audience actually groaned when it happened) I don't remember Achilles being made out to be a sensitive killer with a concious in the Illiad either. There was tons of stuff that just didn't make any sense, so I am going to re-read the Illiad this week to remind myself of how it was supposed to be.

You know it's bad when the audience starts reacting to the plot "twists" and "serious dialogue" with groans and laughter. Most of the time I feel alone in my hatred and disgust for bad movies; this time, the whole theater was with me. :)
 
Ever the voice of discension, I must say I rather enjoyed this picture. First, Eric Bana was a revelation as Hector. He really stood out against Achilles (Brad Pitt) as a Chippendale version of the great warrior. I don't think this movie would have been tolerable without Bana and I may even rewatch "The Hulk" now.

Peter O'Toole as King Priam was his usual self as a skilled, consummate actor. Orlando Bloom as Paris, the pleasure loving son who selfishly "abducted" Helen thus single-handedly brought about the downfall of Troy did a good job of portraying that kind of self-centeredness and immature behavior.

I enjoyed the costumes, though at times it was hard in battle scenes to know which side was which.

Pitt looked fabulous as Achilles, but after the show I found myself mentally trying to recast his role with a better actor...Russell Crow? Maybe he is too old, though.

Helen may have been beautiful, but the actress who portayed her had such a wooden personality, I doubt a "thousand ships" would ever have been launched on her behalf.

The story is too complex to make a shorter movie, but the length was so long that when I got up at the end, my knees wouldn't unbend and I had some painful moments trying to walk. What this movie lacked was compelling dialogue. It did have some cool battle scenes, especially those with Hector. I hated to see him die.

If you are not a history or mythology buff, this movie may not be for you. Save yourmoney for "Shrek 2", "The Day After Tomorrow," "Catwoman"and "Spiderman 2".
 
bunch of people i know went to santa cruz (i am in san jose) why i never know... drive through mountins hour away to see a movie... so i didnt go... geuss i wont see it...:P

Thanks for review... thank god i didnt go... driving to santa cruz because of your friends band gig is one thing... movie... NO

I am waiting for Shrek 2... it should be sooooooooooo awsome!!!!!!!!