• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Tuning to D or C# standard

How would you play in C# or D?

  • Tune your EADG bass down 2-3 steps, and just deal with the floppy strings.

    Votes: 18 20.0%
  • Tune your BEAD bass up 2-3 steps, and have extra-tight strings.

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Just play it on a regular five-string. Use your brain to figure it out.

    Votes: 40 44.4%
  • Get another bass, and tune it to C#. Then C, C#, and D tunings are all only half a step away.

    Votes: 18 20.0%
  • Carrots

    Votes: 14 15.6%

  • Total voters
    90
So....if you want to play in D# standard tuning, you can tune down your EADG bass by one half step.
If you want to play in C standard, you can tune up your BEAD (or five string) bass by one half step. .

What do you do if you want to play C#-F#- B - E? or D-G-C-F? If (for example), you wanted play a lot of A Perfect Circle, who seems to tune to C#? Would you get a special bass just for C# and D tuning? Or would you just learn how to play it on your BEAD or 5 string bass?
 
It depends on how extensively you'll be playing in those tunings. If I were going to be spending a lot of time playing rock/metal music written in tunings with a low string in the D to C range (which I do), I for sure would have a separate bass with a heavier string gauge that better suits those tunings.

If you are just playing a random APC song here and there you could get by on a BEADG five-string though, since their stuff shouldn't be as difficult to play without using their exact tuning compared to other rock and metal bands that rely a lot more on open string palm mutes and very intricate unison parts.
 
I play a most exclusively in those tunings. Either tune 105-45/50 strings down a whole step and raise the action/adjust the intonation and adjust your technique. Currently my D standard bass has 110-55 Ernie balls and it feels good. Personally it’s worth having a bass setup in that tuning
 
So....if you want to play in D# standard tuning, you can tune down your EADG bass by one half step.
If you want to play in C standard, you can tune up your BEAD (or five string) bass by one half step. .

What do you do if you want to play C#-F#- B - E? or D-G-C-F? If (for example), you wanted play a lot of A Perfect Circle, who seems to tune to C#? Would you get a special bass just for C# and D tuning? Or would you just learn how to play it on your BEAD or 5 string bass?

I normally tune to flats now these days (half step down from E standard). But our band started writing some songs in D standard (whole step down from E standard). So I tuned my Fender PJ to DGCF. It depends on how you like your tone IMO. I can't stand the tone/zing I lose when I go to a heavier gauge string (.105 to a .110 set). I still use the .105 set tuned to D standard and it works for me. But if I went down to C#, I'd almost have to go to a .110 set. That is the reason I don't go lower than D standard for the most part.

So IMO, it really depends on if you don't mind getting a darker tone and how lose and or tight you want the bass to feel. If you can play most your songs in D standard with a lighter gauge, that's the route I'd go personally.
 
So....if you want to play in D# standard tuning, you can tune down your EADG bass by one half step.
If you want to play in C standard, you can tune up your BEAD (or five string) bass by one half step. .

What do you do if you want to play C#-F#- B - E? or D-G-C-F? If (for example), you wanted play a lot of A Perfect Circle, who seems to tune to C#? Would you get a special bass just for C# and D tuning? Or would you just learn how to play it on your BEAD or 5 string bass?


I played in C# standard for many years. it was always a challenge to find strings that were not too stiff or not too floppy. i wanted the strings to be on the floppier side for that tone and mostly used 110s or 115s on a 4 string.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: gregmon79
My 4 string and this:

s-l500.webp
 
How you want to play that type of music is up to you but I get a lot of use from having one bass permanently set up in D standard. I actually want a 5 to set up DCCFBb as well. I currently have the Billy Sheehan Rotosounds on my DGCF bass which are 110-80-65-43. I originally tried this with a standard 105-45 set and it was fine except for the floppy D string. That 110 D string was key for me on this setup.