• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Ultra boutique P bass pickups

Well as expected the Ulyate P pickups did not disappoint when mixed with other instruments. They sit in the mix like champs because they are very dynamic and capable of a fair amount of mid highs. The thing that stood out is how good they are at transferring the dynamic element of the musician's playing to the amp.

Comparing them with the Lauzon P/Strat pickup was interesting too. What became obvious is the Ulyate have a bump in the mid and highs. It gives them a crisp top, a clarity that is just terrific. They have that transparency and airy character that are very nice. To some they might be aggressive in the highs but to my ears they never cross that threshold. The Ulyate responded to slapping really well too because of their dynamic character.

The Lauzon P/Strat pups are more balanced across the spectrum and warmer sounding. It also also have a richer harmonic content which is always the trade off between a normal wound and an over wound pickup. The over wound pickup gains in output and fundamental. The normal wound are generally more complex harmonically. All that being said, nobody could ever hear these differences in the mix and I doubt they would even be captured in a recording.

Both the Ulyate and the Lauzon are highly recommended for players who want more output than a regular vintage style pickup but still want something that sound vintage or not as modern as a ceramic pickup.
 
Cool thread! I’m a p-bass guy through and through but haven’t messed around much with high end split p pickups.

I’m a big fan of the Duncan spb-1. The dimarzio model p is cool for that crazy high output thing. The dimarzio area p is a nice refined vintage sounding pickup.

On a whim I just bought a Delano PC 4 AL. From the description it sounds like a mix of what I like, 60s bottom, 70s grind with a little more modern definition.

I’ll post my impressions when it arrives.
 
Cool thread! I’m a p-bass guy through and through but haven’t messed around much with high end split p pickups.

I’m a big fan of the Duncan spb-1. The dimarzio model p is cool for that crazy high output thing. The dimarzio area p is a nice refined vintage sounding pickup.

On a whim I just bought a Delano PC 4 AL. From the description it sounds like a mix of what I like, 60s bottom, 70s grind with a little more modern definition.

I’ll post my impressions when it arrives.
Looking forward to your review.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pbassmanca
Well, I can confirm that Gary at Bass Exchange was absolutely right the Arcane P 65 is a gorgeous sounding pickup. It definitely has a vintage character and sounds somewhere between a Lollar overwound and an Aguilar. What this pickup does is growl, it has a unique growl in the low mids that is really nice. It's warm, not flashy sounding, has perfect string to string balance, a good amount of punch. This is a winner! Highly recommended.

Laurent - do you happen to have any suggestions in terms of pots to pair with this pickup as well as whether they should be 250 or 500?
 
Cool thread! I’m a p-bass guy through and through but haven’t messed around much with high end split p pickups.

I’m a big fan of the Duncan spb-1. The dimarzio model p is cool for that crazy high output thing. The dimarzio area p is a nice refined vintage sounding pickup.

On a whim I just bought a Delano PC 4 AL. From the description it sounds like a mix of what I like, 60s bottom, 70s grind with a little more modern definition.

I’ll post my impressions when it arrives.
I'm also very interested to read a review of the Delano.
 
Looking forward to your review.
I noticed on another post you made, that you are interested in the Fender CS 60's Precision pickups. Have you spent any time playing any basses with this setup? I have played several Precisions with the CS shop pickups installed and have always been impressed with the sound. I'm not sure if they qualify as "ultra boutique", but I feel that they definitely have a very thumpy, dry, woody sound to them with a very useful amount of upper midrange and balanced treble that produces a good vintage tone. Infact, I have long considered whether I should order 1 or 2 of them to try in my P basses and compare to some other P pickup varieties. One of the things that I find interesting is how the tone of the Custom Shop pickups are quite different from that of the "Original" P pickups, even though they share the same specs on paper. I STILL have a set of Klein Epic 62's waiting to be dropped in a P bass that is currently wearing an "Original" P pickup, but I have other work to do on that bass and wanted to do all of the jobs together on that instrument!
 
Does anyone know if any pickup makers are doing a really good late 60's (like 68' or 69' style) reproduction Precision pickup? I've been listening to a lot of Rufus lately and the tone of Bobby Watson's 69' Pbass is just killing me with its aggressive midrange spank, thick lows, and clear yet grindy highs. I played actual 68' and 69' Pbasses last year at a local shop and the sound of those instruments strung with Fender flats were definitely in the same ballpark as what I hear on those Rufus records! (Minus the inimitable skill of Mr. Watson of course ;))
 
  • Like
Reactions: ImprecisionBass
I know I read somewhere in this thread that somebody had a Flying Mojo “The Duck pre-CBS” pickup. Did that pickup ever get installed and, if so, how was it? I’m quite intrigued by this pickup and I can’t seem to find any sound clips, or even decent reviews anywhere. Curious to hear some thoughts on it...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pbassmanca
Can anyone compare a stock Lollar P to a Aggie stock P?
Video clips make the Aggie sound warmer and rounder, the Lollar a little more agressive.
I'm looking for a smooth warm sounding pickup. I don't want a hollow, honky midrange like some P bass pickups have.
Thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Pbassmanca
Can anyone compare a stock Lollar P to a Aggie stock P?
Video clips make the Aggie sound warmer and rounder, the Lollar a little more agressive.
I'm looking for a smooth warm sounding pickup. I don't want a hollow, honky midrange like some P bass pickups have.
Thanks

I’ve got a P (2001) with a Custom Shop ‘62 in it and it is very warm and round. Sounds HUGE compared to my other P (2010) that has the stock pickup in it. And I’ve also heard the Pure Vintage ‘63 pickup is even warmer, rounder, and bigger sounding than the Custom Shop ‘62.

I’ve also got a Lollar currently in transit for my newest project but I went with an overwound one for this bass. I’d be more than happy to share my thoughts on it once everything arrives and I can get this bass put together, though I’m not sure it’ll help you out much.

Still waiting to hear what anybody has to say about the Flying Mojo “The Duck pre-CBS” pickup...
 
Can anyone compare a stock Lollar P to a Aggie stock P?
Video clips make the Aggie sound warmer and rounder, the Lollar a little more agressive.
I'm looking for a smooth warm sounding pickup. I don't want a hollow, honky midrange like some P bass pickups have.
Thanks

Your description is right on. The Aguilar is warmer, rounder and more bassy. The Lollar has more highs and is more complex harmonically. The Lollar can do what the Aguilar does with a bit of tone correction but it's harder to generate more highs if the pickup is not producing these frequencies. Unless you are looking for a really soft round tone, I would go with the Lollar personally. I currently have both pickups BTW. I would also give a nod to the Arcane Experience 65 which sounds even better than the Lollar to my ears; the Arcane might be a great compromise between the Aguilar and the Lollar.

All are amongst the best pickups money can buy for vintage 60's tone.
For more modern tones, I love the DiMarzio Model P, the Ulyate and the Lauzon Strat/P. All are top of the class pickups for a post 70's precision tone.
 
Last edited:
The Arcane 65 Experience, Flying Mojo “The Duck Pre-CBS,” David Allen CS 1088P, and Fender Pure Vintage ‘63 are my top choices to replace the pickup in my 2010 American Standard. The stock pickup in that bass is awful and as badly as I want to break it out on a gig, I just can’t bring myself to do it because I hate the tone so much.
 
The Arcane 65 Experience, Flying Mojo “The Duck Pre-CBS,” David Allen CS 1088P, and Fender Pure Vintage ‘63 are my top choices to replace the pickup in my 2010 American Standard. The stock pickup in that bass is awful and as badly as I want to break it out on a gig, I just can’t bring myself to do it because I hate the tone so much.


Yes to the David Allen CS 1088P! I've tried several, including the Fender PV '63 (in an AVRI), the SD SPB-1, the SD APB-2, Fender CS '62, and the David Allen is by far my favorite. You can get that vintage thumpy tone but you can also get excellent clarity in the highs without any "brittleness". Very smooth and balanced. Seems to response well with the tone control. I have it in an American P bass with Sadowsky flats.
 
  • Like
Reactions: d00dr