• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

undedicated musicians ...i hate ND

hey, i live in north dakota and have only been playing bass for about 2 years, but i'm learning, and i've composed a few songs(i guitar and drum as well)...and even though i've writen these songs i can find no band around my area dedicated to play...should i move and hopefully find a new band...i mean i'm just turning 18....or should i buy some recording gear and pull a trent reznor/Nine Inch Nails...and do it all alone and get a backing band when i play...y cant more guitarist be dedicated....or is it just my lowly state of ND
 
What's more important, being in a band, or playing your own music? As cynical as that sounds, that's what it comes down to, and some people get a rush out of playing with a band and making it big, and that's okay. In my case, what I thought was my dream band a year ago disintigrated, and since then I'm writing, recording, and programming all the parts for two seperate projects that grew out of it. Maybe one day, at least one will become a complete band, but if not, I really don't care because I'm the clipper of my own ship without being held hostage by band members with other priorities.
 
It's hard to find the right mix of people no matter where you live. Age is a factor, but there are "unddicated" musicians at every age. Patience, experimentation, etc. You'll eventually find the right mix.

Getting a band together, and keeping i ttogether are very difficult things to do. It's the nature of the beast. You are dealin gwith personalities, creative diffferences, ego, all kinds of stuff.

Hang in there. You can put together a good band - even here.

I think the more pressing issue is venue. There aren't many places to play.
 
Don't move to find band members, there isn't a better place where people are dedicated to original music, and you will make it.

Here is the reality of being in a band/playing music, money talks bull!@#$ walks. So, you may have wrote some great songs. So, what. Unless you have a record deal inked or paying shows lined up musicians/players don't really care.

And even if you find some players that like your stuff and believe in it they will eventually quit because of one of the following.

1. Not makeing any money.
2. Young and move on to the next band/big thing.
3. young and gets first real girlfriend.
4. Grown and gets married.
5. Gets married and not making any money in your band.
6. Wakes up from dreamland and realizes your band won't be on mtv next week and that trying to make it is actually a lot of work.
7. a.d.d.
8. Goes temporarily insane for no apparent reason.
9. You aren't writing songs/running the show like they think it should be.
10. Plays a few gigs and finds that gigging isn't always fun, especially when you get home at 2 am and have to be at work at 5 am.
11. Plays a few gigs and finds out that getting on stage with a guitar doesn't make hot chicks fall all over ugly guys with no personality.

the list could fill a book.

I've literally had players play with me two time and act like finding my band/original act was like finding the holy grail, then not hear from them ever again.

I'm 36 now, and have always wrote my own songs. People have often said they were good, but it was always hard to keep a band together with the good players.

Why? Because all original, unsigned acts make 0 dollars.

I may sound negative, but that is the reality of finding people who are just more or less hired guns to play your music. I still play in a rock band and write original music, but I'm also lucky enough to be married to my writing partner, my wife. (Lucky, riiiiiiiiight.) So, she's invested in the songs/music. We also have a long time friend who we've known for over decade now, that for some reason sticks around and plays drums in our band.

Being in a band can be fun, but more often that not it's more hassles than it's worth. You really have to look at what you want to do. If you want to gig out, then of course you would need a band. If you can't play all the instruments to record your music you might need a band, or at least know some players.

If you are not so concerned with gigging but want to make demos and try to get a deal, and can play all the instruments you really don't need a band. If you were to get a deal you could put an add in the local musicians wanted and with the fact that you had a deal you'd probably be able to put one together within a couple of weeks if not days.
 
Not is commitment also age-related, it's also a case of what someone really wants to do. I mentioned this in another post: I'm in a band now where we just lost a member who is an "actor" and who basically did the band when he wasn't "acting." We have a guitarist who is in three other bands. Two others are music school graduates who are looking for freelance band/orchestra jobs and put those above the band (although if they will give you money, I can see that but PLEASE LET US KNOW AHEAD OF TIME!). Our bandleader, her best friend and co-writer, and I seem to be the only ones with a) dedication and b) time on our hands to do this. So, it's a matter of age and it's also a matter of How Badly Do You Want It.