• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which for which

Would you like the idea of the tonal character of the string "enhancing and reinforcing" the natural character of the bass? Or, would you rather that the string would "compensate" for what may be lacking in the natural character of the bass?

P = mid-forward, J = scooped.
Roto = mid-forward, Hi Beams = scooped.

P/Roto & J/HB = "reinforce".
P/HB & J/Roto = "compensate".
 
For what it's worth, I've had the same Lull P4 (20 years) and 70s jazz parts bass (40). Rotos on the jazz, Lo Riders (both nickel) on the P.
I'm leaning towards the Rotos on the Jazz for more of a mid boost so I can hear myself better in the mix. The P sits perfectly in the mix but it still has the original Fender strings on it that came on it (which I really like the sound of)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swerve and ahbradot
I haven't tried those ... I'd try the LaBella 760FL which I'd highly recommend for P-bass. That and I'd look to upgrade to a Custom Shop 62 P-bass or Lollar pickups. If you don't like the sound of that combination on a P-bass..... then I'd say its your speakers that need replacing. hahahaha
 

Attachments

  • IMG_5690.JPG
    IMG_5690.JPG
    141.4 KB · Views: 4
Now not to put down a P-bass with rounds. I do love that too. That's why you need 2 P-basses. But thats another story. There, the sky is the limit for Rounds and in which case I'd go ahead and slap the Hi-Beams on there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Froski
J-bass and flats...... I used to dislike that combo and thought of it like peanut butter and mayonnaise. UNTIL...... I bought one that already had Ti Flats on it. That thing is amazing. So yeah, I'm gonna have to agree with you. You need 2 J-bass and 2 P-bass..... hahaha
 
  • Like
Reactions: Froski
I have a player 2 Jazz bass and a player 2 Precision bass. I just bought 2 sets of strings. DR Hi-beams and Rotosound 66s. I'm having a hard time deciding which bass to put which strings on. Any opinions?
Both Basses have the same headstock winding and tuner peg detail. Install. Whatever strings on whatever bass, play for an hour or so. Then take the strings off each bass and restring with the other strings. Take an hour or so. You may come to conclusions based on YOUR experiences and preferences that way. I think you are bound to learn something and have some preference if this is the level of detail and query you're getting into, so YOU be the judge. Let us know YOUR findings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Froski
I have a player 2 Jazz bass and a player 2 Precision bass. I just bought 2 sets of strings. DR Hi-beams and Rotosound 66s. I'm having a hard time deciding which bass to put which strings on. Any opinions?
Try a set of DR LoRiders next go-around. They have a longer life the either of those two.

As for which on which, for me it wouldn’t matter much other than the Rotos prime sound out of the bag is comparatively short lived. Tonally in a band there isn’t too much difference on stage and zero different in the audience.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Froski
I'm leaning towards the Rotos on the Jazz for more of a mid boost so I can hear myself better in the mix. The P sits perfectly in the mix but it still has the original Fender strings on it that came on it (which I really like the sound of)
I too really like my original Fender strings on my 2025 Fender Player II Precision
Your Fender Player II Precision Bass (P-Bass) comes stock with Fender USA 7250M nickel-plated steel strings, specifically in the medium gauge of .045–.105, known for providing a classic punchy tone suitable for rock, blues, and various styles, as noted in Fender's guides and retailer specs.

I have RotoSound RS66LF Swing Bass 66 Stainless Steel Bass Guitar Strings (45 65 85 105) on my 2018 Fender Limited Edition American Professional Jazz Bass
 
Last edited:
I would keep the 7250m’s on the P. But I’m biased as they are my favorite strings. If you like the tension of the Fenders the DR’s will not be as taut feeling since they are roundcore.

If it were me I’d leave the Fenders on the P and put Rotos on the J. The roto/j combo is a classic combo used by the likes of Geddy and Jaco so you can’t really go wrong.

Save the DR’s for a rainy day or another bass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Froski
I too really like my original Fender strings on my 2025 Fender Player II Precision
Your Fender Player II Precision Bass (P-Bass) comes stock with Fender USA 7250M nickel-plated steel strings, specifically in the medium gauge of .045–.105, known for providing a classic punchy tone suitable for rock, blues, and various styles, as noted in Fender's guides and retailer specs.

I have RotoSound RS66LF Swing Bass 66 Stainless Steel Bass Guitar Strings (45 65 85 105) on my 2018 Fender Limited Edition American Professional Jazz Bass
How do you like them on your Jazz bass?
 
I would keep the 7250m’s on the P. But I’m biased as they are my favorite strings. If you like the tension of the Fenders the DR’s will not be as taut feeling since they are roundcore.

If it were me I’d leave the Fenders on the P and put Rotos on the J. The roto/j combo is a classic combo used by the likes of Geddy and Jaco so you can’t really go wrong.

Save the DR’s for a rainy day or another bass.
Solid advice, thanks
 
  • Like
Reactions: Swerve