Which mixer deal to go with...

[NickFromNY]

I currently have a Yamaha MG166cx board that I like, but I am out of channels and I worry about lugging it around week after week with its plastic body. I'd like to upgrade to something with 16 xls inputs and at least 4 aux sends (3 for monitors and one for reverb). I have the chance to get one of the following. Your advice would be appreciated.

Mackie 1604 VLZ3 -$450
Mackie 1604 VLZPro - $300
Mackie CFX20 - $250
Allen & Heath Zed24 -$400
Allen & Heath mix ward 16:2dX $500
Suck it up and keep the Yamaha... It will be fine.

I am open to other suggestions. $500 is my max.

 

[NickFromNY]

All of these are used prices, obviously

 

[projectMalamute]

The Mixwizard, by quite some margin.

 

[NickFromNY]

I've never used Allen & Heath stuff before but I've read great stuff. I was impressed by the feel of the Zed24.

 

[modulusman]

The only one that really sucks is the CFX. If the other mackies are in good working order they will do the job. The mix wiz would be your best bet though.

 

[MNAirHead]

I have several - pay attention to "layout" an intuitive interface is helpful ..... Direct recording to USB will helpful ...

For a live setting , there are some useful onboard effects available

I own Yamaha, mackie, peavey, Bose, motu, Allen & Heath ...... The easiest to use gets the play time

 

[Vinny D]

Never buy a used Mackie 1604VLZ pro...
Way to many with ribbon cable issues and possibly the worst failure rate of any budget mixing board that I know of....and yes, I used to own one.

The best of the bunch you have listed is the MixWiz...for many reasons.
If it's in good shape grab it.

 

[Tunaman]

Vinny D is the man, go with him. Allen & Heath, sweet

 

[NickFromNY]

Thanks for the advice. Picked up a sweet Mixwizard WZ3 16:2 today used on a great deal. I need to work with it a bit but its definately what i needed

 

[Vinny D]

Great choice, I own two of them and they have been solid performers.

 

[TimmyP]

MixWiz if 16 channels will do, otherwise a GL2200.