• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which one?

I’ve received two trade offers, but I can’t decide which one to choose.

It’s between a US Fender Jazz Bass from 2005 and a Lakland 44-01 Skyline from Korea.
There is a Fender 60 detached on the back of the headstock. I guess it’s their 60’s anniversary model…

I don’t have the opportunity to try them out, so I’m hoping for your feedback to help make the decision easier for me.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_9170.jpeg
    IMG_9170.jpeg
    406.6 KB · Views: 20
  • IMG_9171.jpeg
    IMG_9171.jpeg
    97.8 KB · Views: 21
  • IMG_9173.jpeg
    IMG_9173.jpeg
    445.5 KB · Views: 23
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: lowendrachel
I have an Indonesian Skyline and mine is light weight and the neck is very stable. Neck shape and dimensions are my favorite of all my basses. Changed pre and pups and it is killer now. Great mod platform.
Love mine. Hope that helps.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bashke81
As I wouldn't buy a guitar I hadn't tried, I would go with the one with best resale value (and likelihood of shifting quickly) in case I had to get rid of it straight away.

In this case I wouldn't be sure because the only Laklands I tried in a store had all been set up with ridiculously low action and therefore didn't test well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bashke81
obviously, each instrument is an individual. without trying them, this is one of the rare cases where I think i'd go with the fender.

i've actually played several of the 60th anniversary fenders and really liked all of them. I know I owned one - roughly that time, 05 or so, and it was completely killer.

nothing wrong with either choice. a nice ~20 year old USA fender, can be a really nice instrument in many cases.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bashke81
The Lakland, being imported , will not keep its value over time, the U.S. Fender will.

Also, parts for the Fender will always be available and it’s a lifetime instrument, I’m not sure about the Lakland.

If the Lakland was made in USA, that would be a complete different story though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bashke81
The Lakland, being imported , will not keep its value over time, the U.S. Fender will.

Also, parts for the Fender will always be available and it’s a lifetime instrument, I’m not sure about the Lakland.

If the Lakland was made in USA, that would be a complete different story though.

Incorrect. Used Skylines, especially Korean ones from the 2000s/early 2010s, have retained their value on the used market quite well. Comparable with new.

Some Lakland USA parts are interchangeable with Skyline parts, but not necks or bodies. Not sure what you'd have to do to the bass to warrant 'replacing parts', but Lakland makes replacement tuners, etc readily available for most all of their instruments. I was a Lakland Artist for many years and they are one of the best at going out of their way to make something right, and available, if a customer is in need.

As far as the construction and tone of the -01 series, I call bee ess on the notion that the stock electronics (and tones) suck and warrant gutting the instrument from the get-go. All of my 2000s era Korean made -01's have their stock Bartolini MK-1 electronics and I've recorded and performed hundreds of hours and shows with them with great results. The preamp is a little sizzly on top with extreme boosting, but overall you can get very usable, albeit mostly 'modern' sounds out of it as a general rule.... you won't get a tone that will fool anyone for being a Jazz Bass, Precision, or even EBMM. But it has a great tone for what it is. I also have a 44-02 Deluxe with the LH-3 USA electronics package. While it is very different tonally, it's not necessarily 'better' in all instances.... it sounds like a totally different instrument. I still go to my -01 series basses a lot even though I have the -02. FWIW, a Lakland and a Fender Jazz (especially depending on neck profile), balance, play, and feel very different when compared with each other.

In general, the market perception of the Fender will ensure that it will retain its value and likely be easier to resell in the future. But the Skylines, especially the Korean ones, are solid instruments that last.
 
Incorrect. Used Skylines, especially Korean ones from the 2000s/early 2010s, have retained their value on the used market quite well. Comparable with new.

Some Lakland USA parts are interchangeable with Skyline parts, but not necks or bodies. Not sure what you'd have to do to the bass to warrant 'replacing parts', but Lakland makes replacement tuners, etc readily available for most all of their instruments. I was a Lakland Artist for many years and they are one of the best at going out of their way to make something right, and available, if a customer is in need.

As far as the construction and tone of the -01 series, I call bee ess on the notion that the stock electronics (and tones) suck and warrant gutting the instrument from the get-go. All of my 2000s era Korean made -01's have their stock Bartolini MK-1 electronics and I've recorded and performed hundreds of hours and shows with them with great results. The preamp is a little sizzly on top with extreme boosting, but overall you can get very usable, albeit mostly 'modern' sounds out of it as a general rule.... you won't get a tone that will fool anyone for being a Jazz Bass, Precision, or even EBMM. But it has a great tone for what it is. I also have a 44-02 Deluxe with the LH-3 USA electronics package. While it is very different tonally, it's not necessarily 'better' in all instances.... it sounds like a totally different instrument. I still go to my -01 series basses a lot even though I have the -02. FWIW, a Lakland and a Fender Jazz (especially depending on neck profile), balance, play, and feel very different when compared with each other.

In general, the market perception of the Fender will ensure that it will retain its value and likely be easier to resell in the future. But the Skylines, especially the Korean ones, are solid instruments that last.
I guess I like more traditional sounds..Jazz bass...P bass...and Music man

I tried with my 5501 MK1 electronics...and was never truly happy.

Now the 5502 and 4402 with Barts was my love and I was always satisfied

I think the Fender Jazz would be the best option to have....and you cannot beat a good Jazz bass

unless it is a Precision Bass :laugh::bassist:
 
I guess I like more traditional sounds..Jazz bass...P bass...and Music man

I tried with my 5501 MK1 electronics...and was never truly happy.

I hear you. If those tones and those tones alone are what you like, than the -01 series would be too 'modern'. I never went into the -01 series basses expecting them to sound like anything other than what they were. I knew they would not be a Jazz, Precision, or MM, so I was able to evaluate the sound(s) on offer on their own terms. I wanted 'modern'. Going on 20 years with all of my Laklands, and my -01 series instruments still play and sound great. I guess my point is that sound is subjective, but some of the responses on these boards where people say the -01 series and their electronics 'suck' or that the basses are 'inferior' because of where they are/were made is just perpetuation of subjective opinions and not facts. My goal is to offer firsthand, real world, in the trenches experience as someone who has played and lived with the -01 series instruments (4 and 5 string, and fretless) for 2 decades.... just so objective info is out there.
 
Ah, I see. That’s a quite nice feature
I have a Jazz with a push/pull series mod--I use series all the time, it's kind of its own sound--fatter in the mids than just favoring the front pickup in parallel. Assuming the S1 works similarly it also means then you just have one volume control when in series mode which is also handy for live I find.
That horseshoe...is that screwed into the wood, or just glued on somehow?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bashke81
I have a Jazz with a push/pull series mod--I use series all the time, it's kind of its own sound--fatter in the mids than just favoring the front pickup in parallel. Assuming the S1 works similarly it also means then you just have one volume control when in series mode which is also handy for live I find.
That horseshoe...is that screwed into the wood, or just glued on somehow?
Screwed with two screws
 

Latest posts