• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why are people obsessed with weight??

Early 40's now bro. i've played heavy basses and enjoyed the heck out of the tone - i sometimes borrow my pal's P bass which weighs a ton. Heck, my new (to me) USA hamer B12L is pretty stout.

I have a bad T9 disk (bring out the violins) but even if I didn't it's all about the amount of time you play at a gig.

I liken it to meeting a drummer who brings a piece (or larger) kit to a gig. First thing I think is "you don't gig much do you?" - Virtually all the pro and working drummers i know use 4 pc kits because they're sick of lugging around one more thing. I know some cats gig a lot with 8x10 and 2x15 cabs, but if you did a poll based upon number of gigs a person plays - you'd find a very large skew towards bringing smaller gear (maybe two smaller cabs, lighter head, etc). I see the same thing with PA size - the band that plays once a month or less brings a monster, while the band that plays every week brings a more efficient system.

I said all that to kinda set the stage - If you gig a lot, you're probably going to gravitate towards lighter basses. Most gigs I do now are two LONG sets. a kilo makes a huge difference over the course of 1.5-2 hours during a set.

This isn't unique to musicians - find someone who does anything very frequently - (hobby or professionally) where they have to schlep stuff around and or hold it for a long period of time and more often than not they're using lighter more efficient stuff, and bringing only what they need.

I get what you're saying. I've always wanted to get a BIG rig to play out live. I had an SWR 4x10 that weighed around 100 lbs and it was ridiculous to carry. I ended up getting a Dr. Bass 2x12 and have enjoyed that cab quite a bit. It's more compact and light. I did add a 15 to it for a while, but realized that I was defeating my original goal of being portable.


Ditto. I always giggle when someone states "I play a 12 lb bass just fine, stop being a sissy". Then later slips that they do 45 minute shows with 5 other bands.

It isn't about the first hour... it's about the 4th or 5th hour.

I never say things like that, but I do enjoy playing basses in the 9-10 lb range. I've played 3-4 hour sets with them without problems. I had an SR5 once that weighed 13ish lbs. Had a great sound, but it was just too heavy to gig with constantly.
 
I've played 3-4 hour sets with them without problems. I had an SR5 once that weighed 13ish lbs. Had a great sound, but it was just too heavy to gig with constantly.

IMHO the problem comes into play the 3rd or 4th day of 4 hour sets each day. I'm fine with 9.5lbs +/- but over 10 and I know I'm going to start feeling it. So I just try to stay away from things over 9.5 when possible.
 
IMHO the problem comes into play the 3rd or 4th day of 4 hour sets each day. I'm fine with 9.5lbs +/- but over 10 and I know I'm going to start feeling it. So I just try to stay away from things over 9.5 when possible.

that's it right there - one gig? who cares? you're sore the next day, then it's all good. OK - now you have 3 this weekend, 2 the next, a rehearsal with no chair on Wednesday, only one gig next week, then 3 gigs the next - different story.
 
Or multiple gigs in a day. Next sat I'll have two afternoon shows in different locations, then a single 2+ hour set at night. I've optimized my set up to be light and easy to schlep while still sounding good.

Sorry to dissapoint the haters, but I'm not overweight. Years of accumated sports injuries, motorcycle crash, and other things conspire to get in the way of playing. Despite a day job, tendinitis, etc I've done 80+ gigs this year. I'm just happy to be playing this year as I turn 50. Hope you young whippersnappers aren't wasting your healthy backs and hands :D
 
My thoughts are the same. Most people who complain about it are probably (just by the odds) 40 pounds overweight and have very little muscle mass, but they don't complain about that do they? Yeah but if a bass is 11 pounds instead of 9, it's a travesty.

Lose some weight and get a little stronger. It's not a big deal.

And if you were in really good shape, you can play bass with more strings - because, you know, if you're overweight, you can't play more than a 4 banger. Lose some strings, it's not a big deal. ;)
 
IMHO the problem comes into play the 3rd or 4th day of 4 hour sets each day. I'm fine with 9.5lbs +/- but over 10 and I know I'm going to start feeling it. So I just try to stay away from things over 9.5 when possible.

that's it right there - one gig? who cares? you're sore the next day, then it's all good. OK - now you have 3 this weekend, 2 the next, a rehearsal with no chair on Wednesday, only one gig next week, then 3 gigs the next - different story.

I get what you guys are saying. I'm not currently in a band that gigs that regularly. I was about a year ago though. We usually would play Friday evening, Saturday evening, and then Sunday morning and evening as well.
 
Yeah? So?

I laughed out loud.

I mean, if the bass drum is miced, all the dancers need is a room full of bassilicous sound and that thump on 1 nd 3. They'll be fine . . .

Obviously, for some guys the big rig is all they've got. If they play at an aprpriate level, it's all good. There's a chance the singer can actually hit the notes. I wanna hear it when that happens. If the bassist is cranking to get "their sound" at 120 dB, it's a problem. One that many guitar players have with much smaller amplification . . .
 
Wow this thread is really starting to get off track. "My rig is bigger than your rig" LOL

To the OP, I think for the "working guys" like me 40+ years old playing in the trenches on Friday (4+ sets) and Saturday (4+ sets) and then some of us play an odd gig during the week and even a few more of us playing Sunday mornings at church, (all of which I do) a bass that weighs more than say, 10lbs is: 1. not necessary and 2. gets too heavy and starts to hurt my shoulder around Midnight. And yes, I use a padded wide strap.

Call me a "weenie" or call me what you want, but a 12lbs bass would really take the enjoyment out of playing for me.

BTW, I still love my big rig (just got a new one) cause it has wheels and I don't have to carry it for 4 hours and just like all the tools in my tool box, I know where and when to use it.

So there's my 3 cents for what it's worth.
 
Ditto. I always giggle when someone states "I play a 12 lb bass just fine, stop being a sissy". Then later slips that they do 45 minute shows with 5 other bands.

It isn't about the first hour... it's about the 4th or 5th hour.

Exactly comparing a 45 minute show every fourth weekend to giggin' 5 sets a nite 5 days a week is a case of comparing apples to oranges