I joined a fusion rock band and the band leader asked if I wouldn't mind playing a 5. I got a 5 and played it for 8 years but after that ended, I could not move back to 4's fast enough. I just don't like 5 string. 4 strings is home.
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Why do you play fours?
- Thread starter twinjet
- Start date
-
- Tags
- four string
All of the 5 string bass necks I've tried are either too wide or have the strings too close together for comfort. I usually have a second instrument on hand to allow for a rapid switch to Drop-D or E-flat tuning, but the few songs that require those use the open low string heavily, so using a 5-string with a low B string instead is a lot more awkward.
I actually own a 5-string bass (and 6 with 4 strings) and haven't even picked that one up in at least a year. At some point, I had one bass restrung for BEAD tuning, but only used it on one song. When the band stopped playing that song, I switched it back to normal strings.
As pointed out by previous posters, the 5-string only gains you 5 extra notes, and I'm not overly impressed with the tonal quality of the low-B strings I've played, to put it mildly.
I actually own a 5-string bass (and 6 with 4 strings) and haven't even picked that one up in at least a year. At some point, I had one bass restrung for BEAD tuning, but only used it on one song. When the band stopped playing that song, I switched it back to normal strings.
As pointed out by previous posters, the 5-string only gains you 5 extra notes, and I'm not overly impressed with the tonal quality of the low-B strings I've played, to put it mildly.
Is his playing as one note as his acting?
I'm so thick I can't even count to 5 without looking at my hands to cheat.
That's not John Wick, that's Bill.... or Ted............or somebody.
All I know is if a couple girls buried me up to my head and tried to run it over with a lawnmower, I'd pitch a much bigger bitch than he did.
He's a method actor, studied at the "Gene Simmons School of Bass?"
1. My upright (double bass, doghouse bass, contrabass, whatever) is four strings.
2. My only fretless electric bass is four strings.
3. I prefer five strings on a general-purpose electric bass guitar but four can be fun also: It makes me think a little differently, and that's a good thing.
2. My only fretless electric bass is four strings.
3. I prefer five strings on a general-purpose electric bass guitar but four can be fun also: It makes me think a little differently, and that's a good thing.
I prefer 5s (see avatar). But they're heavier. I'm older. $s are lighter.
Built this parts bass, functionally like my avatar, but 1.5 pounds lighter. No regrets.
Built this parts bass, functionally like my avatar, but 1.5 pounds lighter. No regrets.
As an addendum to my previous post:
I have played around with 5ers at various music stores. The lowB would be handy to have for some of the music we play.
The Squier CV 5s are very playable basses, good quality, and priced nicely. On more than one occasion I almost walked out with one.
What stopped me? I'm sure you can guess. They weigh about 75lbs. And I come to my senses and realize there is no way I can wear this instrument for a 2.5 hour show.
I'll stick with my very comfortable 4 and drop the E the 4 or 5 times I need that low D (or Eb) during a gig.
I have played around with 5ers at various music stores. The lowB would be handy to have for some of the music we play.
The Squier CV 5s are very playable basses, good quality, and priced nicely. On more than one occasion I almost walked out with one.
What stopped me? I'm sure you can guess. They weigh about 75lbs. And I come to my senses and realize there is no way I can wear this instrument for a 2.5 hour show.
I'll stick with my very comfortable 4 and drop the E the 4 or 5 times I need that low D (or Eb) during a gig.
Does that thing include a propellor and motor so you can fly it to your next gig?
