Sorry I took so long to respond, I was on a bit of vacation in Montreal. cool city, great food. Unfortunately I left as they were setting up for the jazz festival.
I am glad that my comment got you thinking (that's what it is supposed to do). It is also probably the best question I've seen at talkbass. I am going to try and breakdown your comments and give you an answer. But let me preface everything here by one comment, there is no substitute for time. Internalizing comments is difficult and takes time.
TheChris said:
My question ties in a bit with Pacman 's sure fire scale practice method - how does learing scales help me play in a band?
It is relatively easy to learn the bass lines that others have written/played. I have a number of students who can play all of Victor Wooten's material but have absolutely no idea how to play through a simple blues. The goal is to be able to create your own bass lines - either over a tune that you already do or some cover tunes.
Scales, unfortunately are not musical. There is very little about drilling scales that will help you play tunes. Playing scales will help in developing techniques. Playing scales will help develop your ear. Each of these is good, however they are not inherently musical.
I approach scales in a very different way, a much simpler way than learning all the modes and a way that is much more melodic, musical and musically applicable ... I'll get there in a few minutes
TheChris said:
I've been through two teachers in this area, and maybe it's me, but I don't quite grasp how drilling on scales is helping at all. Maybe in the figer dexterity dept, sure. Learning the fretboard dept, sure. But how do I get to the point where I know instantly the "appropriate chord scales and modes"?
Since I do not know your knowledge base, please forgive me if some of the examples are too simple or if I have glossed over something that needs more of an explanation.
You don't have to nknow "instantly" - you just have to take a moment to look at the tune and figure out a Key Center or Tonal Center. Here is one example, you have a song that is G, C, D, G. We can fairly quickly tell that this is in the key of G. How? well In any major key, the chord based on the first, fourth and fifth scale degrees (I,IV,V) are major chords. The chords based on the second, third and sixth (II,III,VI) are minor chords. Finally the chord based on the seventh degree(VII) is a diminshed chord. In the above example we have 3 major chords. We can look for the I, IV, V relationship. It only works if the key is G. A I,IV, V in C would be C,F,G and in D would be D,G,A. We really don't have to worry about all the modes (trust me on this). Then two things that I think about when I approach this are:
1. All the notes in the key of G in any given position
2. The arpeggios of each of the chord
By doing this you can easily outline the harmony using chord tones of the indivdual chords and create lines and fills that work within the key.
NOW!!!! here is the crux of my technique. You play ALL the notes in the key or the arpeggio in any given position, not just from the root up. In the case of a 4 string, in 2nd position, all the notes in the key of G are:
F#,G,A,B,C,D,E,F#,G,A,B,C
The G arpeggio is: G,B,D,G,B
The C Arpeggio is: G,C,E,G,C
The D Arpeggio is: F#,A,D,F#,A,C
In this way, three things happen:
1. You can learn every note in every key using only 5 simple "scale forms" (all the notes in a key in a single position). Each of the 5 scale forms start on a different note of the scale.
Scale Form 1 starts on the 7th degree of the scale
Scale Form 2 starts on the 2nd degree of the scale
Scale Form 3/4 starts on the 3rd degree of the scale
Scale Form 5 starts on the 5th degree of the scale
Scale Form 6 starts on the 6th degree of the scale
Note: some of these might have a little position shift.
2. Your bass lines and arpeggios go in both directions, not just root up which is one of those things that gets boring and predictable
3. in any position 3 or 4 of the modes are covered.
Now within each scale form there are 7 arpeggios (one for each chord). That represents 35 different arpeggios. By doing this you will have every triad in every key in any position on the bass. (35 more when you are ready to add 7th chords)
Learning 5 scale forms and 35 arpeggio forms is not that difficult. By first finding a key center you can create all these bass lines in one position on the neck (2 if you want to get jiggy with it). You will have the arpeggios and scales you need - no problem.
Let's look at one more example: The chord progression is Bm, G, D, A. If we look for the I,IV,V relationship, we can assertain that this is a VI, IV, I, V in the key of D. In 2nd position (where the money is) I'll use scale form 3/4 (F#, the lowest note in that psotion, on a 4 string, is the 3rd of the key of D, hence scale form 3/4). The notes are:
F#,G,A,B,C#,D,E,F#,G,A,B
The arpeggios are:
Bm: F#,B,D,F#,B
G: G,B,D,G,B
D: F#,A,D,F#,A
A: A,C#,E,A
You now have all the tools to create your own line.
TheChris said:
I know what it says in the books - that this mode works well over this chord (like mixolydian over dominant, right?), but how do you internalize all that? It would take me a few moments (or minutes, depending) to figure out the notes in a certain chord, and then to place a mode over it... gah... is it just practice and repetition? Never have been good at that... Like languages vs. math - math is easy, once you understand the concepts. Foreign languages are tough; memorizing is tedious and difficult (for me at least -- my wife is the opposite).
You don't have to fiigure out the notes of the chord, just know the pattern. Your fingers will learn the pattern if you practice enough (muscle memory). Since I don't work in "modes", per se, I don't worry about it. I have my 5 scale forms!
TheChris said:
I've got a number of good books, like Serious Electric Bass, Fretboard Harmony, Levine's Jazz Theory, and yours, but I can't seem to figure out how to learn it in a way that will be helpful in a rock band context. I want to be able to jam and play covers, etc. and it seems that the more effective way to get to that level is to learn Zeppelin, The Who, etc. - it would certainly impress band mates and get me hired, wouldn't it? That, vs, "Hey guys, check out this mixolydian scale in G major - freaky, eh? Now, go ahead, play a D dominant!!"
If you want to jam, then you must know how to create your own lines, not just learn the lines of others. Definetly learn what the masters did .. but then also KNOW how and why they did. I shared a cover of Bassics mag with John paul Jones - how cool is that!
TheChris said:
gah.. sorry, been bubbling up for a number of weeks, and your comment set it off.

Your comment makes sense Mike, I just don't know how to get there.
Be patient!
Mike