• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Mesa vs. Aguilar 1x12 review

pickles

Gold Supporting Member
Mar 23, 2000
10,454
2,836
Ventura, CA
A fairly recent convert to 12" speakers and the mini-stack in particular, I've been very fond of my Aguilar GS series 12s. I've got the 412 and two 112s.

Since I've been running them with a Mesa Boogie M-pulse 600 I decided to pick up a pair of the powerhouse 1x12s to try. Here is my first-week review compared to the Aguilars:

Cons:

* Heavier than the GS. A pretty challenging 1 hand carry, but unlike Aguilar they provide two handles. Carrying one at a time is trivial, and I can still do one in each hand if I want to (but its pretty heavy for that).

* Corners don't stack-lock. Just a nit.

Pros:

* Tone. At first, at low volume, I thought I liked the Aguilar better. But as I moved the volume up toward playing level, I realized how great the powerhouse sounds. It has a LOT more low end, but the lows are very focussed and clear. It has full and smooth low mids, slightly less middle mids (dips somewhere around 500-600), and a lower voiced top end with plenty of note-defining high mids. It also has a very immediate response across the spectrum. Overall it has more of a rock sound. Somewhere between the Aguilar sound and my Aguilar + BDDI sound. It has some real authority along with a great toneful vibe and I love it. My distortion sounds MUCH better through this cab and I never used the BDDI (which I used on rock songs with the Aguilar). The Aguilar still sounds great, especially for less aggressive styles. I'll probably keep them both.

* Volume. The Mesas are significantly louder than the Aguilars. The sensitivity listed on the Mesa is 105db, and I believe it.

* Look. C'mon they just look really cool.

* Features: The crossover settings allow for a lot of different top end sounds. If you want some real snarl ... its there for you! Or you can make it sound shiny and modern ... or mellow. Twin speakons AND twin 1/4 jacks ... its very well thought out.

I'll report back as time goes on.
 
hey Pickles, all of what you said I agree with completely. I have the GS and the Powerhouse 12 myself (tried to sell them recently) and the Powerhouse just has an edge on all fronts over the Aggie (at least the one I have anyway).

Now, if I could just get some kind of deal going for a Mesa 2x15, I'd be set ;)

Enjoy the Powerhouse 12's
 
PICS PLEASE...:p

12s.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mystic Michael
The differences you describe between the Mesa cabs and the GS's mirrors what I hear between the GS's and the new DB's, with the DB's being warmer, louder, punchier and smoother than the wider GS's. Just FYI, in case you want to stay in the Aguilar family!

That being said, the Mesa cabs are beautiful!
 
I'll have to try the DBs at some point just out of curiosity. Its funny how all these different cabs made from a basically identical design concept sound a little different.

I forgot to mention that these cabs don't just rock. I did a wee bit of slapping on the 55-94 between songs and it sounded really killer. These cabs are really quick and have great texture in the highs ... and with the new lakland electronics it was a monster thumb tone.

I still love the GSs as well!
 
I would be interested to know how the Mesa's compare to the Ampeg 112's. I have a pair of those and they are not efficient, but handle a ton of power and sound great. Sadly, they appear to now be discontinued.
 
I've been waiting for such a comparison for a long time. Thanks Pickles.

Now the only thing missing is if you could compare the same kit running through the DB 750. But i guess i'll be finding out for myself before that. I intend on making a field trip and bring my complete Aguilar kit to a store where they have some Mesa and compare both side to side and doing mix-matches between them and maybe throw in some other makes like genz-benz just for the fun of it.

Of course, i'll let you know what i find.

Mark
 
I've tried the DB659 with my 4x12 ... I thought it sounded kind of foggy with those cabs when I played with the band (sounded GREAT solo). I couldn't dial in a solid punchy low end like I wanted. It sort of reminded me of a saxaphone ...

Be sure to compare the DB750 to an M-pulse while you're there :D
 
That's exactly whay i intend to do.

I'll be bringing my DB 750 and GS 2x12 to compare it side by side with an M-pulse 600 and a Powerhouse 2x12. Then I'll try the M-pulse on the GS and the DB on the powerhouse.
 
That'll be fun.

Remember what I said about first impressions ... the mesa gear really shines in the mix IMO, you may find that the Aguilars sound creamier and wonderfully natural and detailed in this comparison, but on the gig I think the mesas have the edge.