• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass Are cheap synthetic hair bows completely worthless?

N

nd1084

Aug 17, 2009
2
0
#1
I recently started playing the upright, mostly pizzicato, but I'm learning to use a bow also. I bought the cheapest bow (German / $40) I could find because I am not committed to sticking with the bow, but playing with this bow is terribly painful. I am wondering how much of it is the cheapness of the bow and how much of it is me being a student. I am using Sherman's Rosin. The sound is so scratchy. It seems like no matter how fluid I am, I can't avoid getting the screeching sound to some degree. I do not have much money to spend. Are these cheap synthetic hair bows completely worthless?
 
#3
Maybe not worthless... but as a beginner, you should probably at least get into a bow with some real hair on it. Maybe you can find an experienced bassist nearby with a decent bow that you can try, just so you know how it could be.

I don't know about Sherman's rosin. As a beginner, you're likely to screech no matter what bow you're playing, unless you get some arco training from a pro teacher.
 
#4
Not completely worthless in the sense that it contributed to the daily income of some asian kid, but in a playing sense, yes, toss that POS.

I think you may end up in a catch 22 with arco. You say youre not sure whether you want to pursue it, yet if you dont buy a semi decent bow now youre not going to enjoy playing arco. Cheap scratchy unbalanced stiff bows are no fun.
 
#8
this is kind of an odd approach to take, but i just thought i'd share this:

i played on a sh*tty bass all through college, and then when i started bowing, i played for a year on a really cheap bow. the combination of the two produced a super sh*tty sound almost always at first, and then, in a painfully slow process, i ended up with a fairly decent tone on a lame instrument set up.

why do i mention this? cause when i got a pretty nice upright (upton hybrid) and a pretty nice bow (finale carbon), the sound that came out was ENORMOUS and the tone was waaaaaay more awesome than i would have ever expected to have achieved playing with good equipment.

the other side of that idea is that bad equipment can teach you bad form and injure you - which is not something to f--- with. but just a thought: don't worry too much about the quality of your rig starting out (although i'd spend more than 40 bucks on a bow)
 
#11
Ed Fuqua said:
You can get plastic/fiberglass (NOT carbon fiber) bows with real hair, they ain't nothing to write home about, but they get you started. They run about $60 at Ideal...
Click to expand...

I agree. That's the setup I have. I've been learning (be it slowly) for a number of years now and that's the set up I have and it definitely gets the job done.... At least in my world of practicing.

Best of luck.
 
#14
I'd suggest either buying a bow with real hair or get yours rehaired...the rehair will cost at least as much as your current bow was.

I had a cheap bow rehaired and i liked it even more. I bought one of the Gollihur Brazilwood bows. It's not an amazing bow, but for $150-it's quite adequate for my needs at the moment.
 
#17
haha, in my experience, all cheap middle-school-owned quality bows are good for is, as someone earlier said, is having sword fights with. However, don't go out and buy a new one quite yet. Try a variety of rosins (i use Nymans, it's great), and see if you can borrow a nicer bow from a friend or something. If you decide to stick with bowing, a decent buy would be carbon-fiber. great tone, virtually indestructable, and fairly cheap.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back