• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

5 string a whole step down

The guitar tuning (switch from perfect 4ths to a major third) makes sense when you are playing 4+ strings simultaneously. I read a study a while back that someone even ran some kind of computer program to determine if there was a more efficient way to tune a guitar, given the purpose and physical ability of the human hand, and it said the standard tuning was actually the most efficient way to make it work.

Of course, most bass players are not playing 4+ strings at once, and as such, the instrument doesn't need to be tuned to make that an efficient thing to do. Since the bass is already in perfect 4ths it makes sense to keep all strings that way, which makes all of your shapes and modes symmetrical and linear. Given that a bass player might reasonably play 2 or 3 strings at once, but much less often 4 (save for tapping, which would be a different tuning question entirely) it makes the most sense to maintain perfect 4ths tuning so those shapes are in alignment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Riff Ranger
Is he being sophomoric? The phrase G String can also refer to a particular garment. Maybe he is trying to joke as if he's talking about the garment and not your bass string?

Of course, if that IS the case, the joke doesn't make sense because the string isn't tuned to G for you. No surprise, he is a guitar player after all.
 
Why does he care? Are you playing the music correctly? Had a guitarist inquire about me playing with him and he asked me if I tune down. I told him I play a 5 string that there was no need. He kept insisting. I ghosted him.
for my heavier stuff i play guitar tuned to c# minor chord and bass standard eadg. i prefer a more melodic bass for riffing so downtuning doesn't sound nearly as cool to me (chose c# because my lowest note on the bass is the third of the lowest guitar chug chord). the "bass has to be tuned an octave below the guitar" crowd bores me