whose argueing ? Go ahead and spend a pile of money chasing the elusive tone, its your money. I could care less, just giving my 2 cents worth, I know what I know, your results may vary.
When I say argument, I don't mean a yelling-match. By definition, offering your 2 cents is making an argument.
But this is a very pointless conversation.
Oh, and I don't spend a pile of money. I have 2 rather cheap basses and will likely not get a much more expensive one. I just don't think saying "it's in the players hands" when someone asks an equipment related question is very smart.
