• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

A CL Lesson in How to NOT Attract Talent

“We are longtime musicians who play bossa nova and jazz and are seeking a female vocalist. Just joking about the fertile part.”

Hmmmm. I’d say that this scores a solid 10 on the douche scale.

I don’t think they’ll get any replies that actually want to work with them... but I’d like to see the replies they do get...
 
Why do you need a video if you aren't really going to play out?

This right here.

We don't want to waste any time with singers who aren't what we are looking for.
We've mostly gotten responses from loud, brassy, show tune types that we consider inappropriate for the material.

So why aren't you linking videos of your performances or at least audio for the potential candidates to review before they decide to waste their time on you? You know, two way street and all that. Do you think it's realistic to expect people to furnish audio/video of their playing for a project that you admit is just for fun and probably won't be performing?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr_Moo
This right here.



So why aren't you linking videos of your performances or at least audio for the potential candidates to review before they decide to waste their time on you? You know, two way street and all that. Do you think it's realistic to expect people to furnish audio/video of their playing for a project that you admit is just for fun and probably won't be performing?

Yes...we do think it's realistic for any musician responding to have clips of themselves in 2019 A.D..
I have clips of myself to submit when I respond to an ad and we have links of ourselves to provide in return if asked.
And I didn't say we probably wouldn't be performing. I said that performance was a possibility.
This is the first musical situation I've been in that is primarily just for the enjoyment of the music itself and the playing of it and we're putting that out front.
I think it's totally reasonable to ask for examples of someone's abilities (and to provide some) before getting involved to any degree.
YMMV
 
Last edited:
the ad indicated jazz cats --- sometimes jazzers get a little outside on that humor thing. i thought it was funny.

Well, that's another misstep on the part of the guitarist. I'm primarily a '50s & '60s R&R, country, blues, R&B, pop kinda guy. This bossa nova thing is new to me. I've loved the music forever but have never played it before this. I think he's taking liberties with his postings that I would not. That's why I'm happy to keep it to ourselves for now.
 
Yes...we do think it's realistic for any musician responding to have clips of themselves in 2019 A.D..
I have clips of myself to submit when I respond to an ad and we have links of ourselves to provide in return if asked.
And I didn't say we probably wouldn't be performing. I said that performance was a possibility.
This is the first musical situation I've been in that is primarily just for the enjoyment of the music itself and the playing of it and we're putting that out front.
I think it's totally reasonable to ask for examples of someone's abilities (and to provide some) before getting involved to any degree.
YMMV

Cool. So why doesn't your craigslist ad link to some material right away? If it's so important, why beat around the bush?