• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass a composer asks about a double-stop

K

KevinRaftery

Jan 26, 2013
2
0
London
#1
Sorry, there's not a bass player near me, so I hope someone will take pity on a composer who wants to get it right but also stretch the envelope a little bit.

If my attachment has come through, you'll see that I'd like to write a pizzicato double-stop at the low end of the instrument. I don't think the glissando will be a problem, as long as you can play bottom F and bottom C# to begin with.

In my mind the F could be played with the thumb. Non-standard, certainly, but this is for a solo, and I expect the player to be very good (although I don't know who it will be).

Am I dreaming? Many thanks.
 

Attachments

  • PizzGliss.png
    PizzGliss.png
    1.9 KB · Views: 173
#2
An approach using the thumb technique is near impossible. Just the leverage is the problem. Now attempting this, I am able to stretch from f natural to c#, but I also have abnormally large hands, the average bassist might have smaller hands. It may require a bassist of more skill than me for the thumb technique, but I don't think its possible.
 
#4
agreatheight said:
Right hand tap?
Click to expand...

I think you're on the wrong side, buddy.

In regards to OP:

It is possible, but it wouldn't be much fun. Like the previous poster said, it might be do able with a thumb, but playing an F natural on the E string with a thumb would be a bitch.

Out of thumb position (down low) Double basses can usually have stops of a fifth, major third, minor third, fourth, and an augmented fourth. You might be lucky to find a player with massive hands.

Check out Bertram Turetzky's The Modern Contrabass; it was written for composers just like yourself to inform themselves of what the modern double bass is capable of.
 
#6
It's a stretch to reach both the F and C# but not impossible.

But, because of the range and the intervals, I can tell you it will sound like a pile of turd even if it is played perfectly.

Although if you really want a wobbly tritone sounding, it would probably sound best to have to play the C# to B gliss on beats 1 & 2 with the second finger, hold the B and play the F on beat 3 with the first finger.
 
#8
This is absolutely possible. I just tried it and it sounds super sweet.

To be fair, it's a little complicated. But it's also been done before. Scodanibbio's "Jardins d'Hamilcar" has an extended passage where the bassist slides between a low F and F-sharp with his thumb while playing the sounding-A harmonic (under the D) on the A-string.

You'll need a player who is comfortable with such a technique.
 
#12
MartinBorgen said:
probably only for sitting players, but probably doable, if a little practise is put on it.
Click to expand...

I gave it a shot standing and it did not work for me. Once I sat down, I started to think that it could be made to happen. I was having trouble keeping my hand curved as I made the gliss, but keeping the F down wasn't too bad.

If you go ahead with it, consider what comes before and after, because getting into thumb position that low will require a transition that's unfamiliar. The left hand may come off the neck (or nearly come off) as the thumb comes around to close the F; also, I had to bring the neck closer to my head into more of a cello position. People who already use that posture may not have as big of an adjustment.

Also, that's not going to be a particularly loud register on the bass, so it might not ring out as much as you'd hope.
 
#13
Alternative suggestion... I don't have a bass handy to try this. Why not stop the F as per normal, and use the RIGHT hand index finger on the C#, plucking them both with 3rd and 4th fingers of the right hand? Pretty much the equivalent of the BG tap technique, without the wimpyness of taps on DB.
 
#15
I wouldn't do a double stop anymore than a fifth on the lower range. If it were something under a (lowest space on bass cleft... Or technically the first a below the staff) we could just do it in thumb position. it's possible to do (like others have stated) but It'd be more "considerate" to just do it div. I know people who would throw a fit over something like that. But it is pretty cool.
 
#17
AClark said:
I wouldn't do a double stop anymore than a fifth on the lower range. If it were something under a (lowest space on bass cleft... Or technically the first a below the staff) we could just do it in thumb position. it's possible to do (like others have stated) but It'd be more "considerate" to just do it div. I know people who would throw a fit over something like that. But it is pretty cool.
Click to expand...

It's no big deal. You finger the F first finger and pivot the rest of the hand a half step higher. Easy to do and it opens a new world of possibilities of techniques.
Tom Gale
Asodb.org
 
#19
If you use a Low D tuning, it's easier. How about 2 on the F and 4 and 1 on the C sharp and B?
Tom Gale
Asodb.org

P.s. By pivoting, you will return shortly to the original hand position. It is a little different than using the extension or, as I call it, "open hand" technique.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back