• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

A good 4 string bass to tune B E A D

I've never tried this, but I was reading in a Gary Willis book that you can increase the tension by adding about a half inch to the string by sliding the string through a circuit board spacer before stringing it through the bridge.
 
I've never tried this, but I was reading in a Gary Willis book that you can increase the tension by adding about a half inch to the string by sliding the string through a circuit board spacer before stringing it through the bridge.

That is a myth, there is no way it will work, a string's pitch is determined by the tension within the speaking length (nut to saddle), any change to the string beyond this, headstock or bridge, will not affect it, it still has to come to the same tension to give the same pitch.

This technique might work on taper core strings, in effect pulling the taper beyond the saddle, and out of the equation, but I've never tried it with tapers.
 
That is a myth, there is no way it will work, a string's pitch is determined by the tension within the speaking length (nut to saddle), any change to the string beyond this, headstock or bridge, will not affect it, it still has to come to the same tension to give the same pitch.

This technique might work on taper core strings, in effect pulling the taper beyond the saddle, and out of the equation, but I've never tried it with tapers.

Like I said, I never tried it and you may be right. I've tried to think of the physics of making the string longer. May be worth a try. Since the string is longer there would need to be more tension to get it tuned up. (I think)
 
Like I said, I never tried it and you may be right. I've tried to think of the physics of making the string longer. May be worth a try. Since the string is longer there would need to be more tension to get it tuned up. (I think)

Only if you make the string longer between the nut and bridge saddle, as in a scale length change. How much string you use beyond the nut or saddle cannot change how much tension it needs to reach a pitch. This has been done to death on the forums. Another one was adding a string tree to strings that don't normally have them(eg, B-E), this also dose not work.

Also, fyi, I did in fact try it(and the string tree method) on a few different B strings, just to see, and it had no effect whatsoever. For BEAD tuning, on a standard 34" bass, all you need is a good set of strings. I've tried it with 5 string sets and standard light guage 4 string sets, all you need is the right strings for you, and a good setup.
 
Regarding the OP, I've tuned several basses B-F#-B-E for one of my current projects (currently using a Zon and a Cort). They all sound fine and they're all 34". I use 135, 90, 70, 50 D'Addario Nickels (ordered as inidividual strings through D'Addario's site).
 
The more I thought about it the more of what you said makes sense. The tension between the nut and bridge would still need to be the same.

I guess I'm going to have to email Willis and give him some crap.

Cheers.


Only if you make the string longer between the nut and bridge saddle, as in a scale length change. How much string you use beyond the nut or saddle cannot change how much tension it needs to reach a pitch. This has been done to death on the forums. Another one was adding a string tree to strings that don't normally have them(eg, B-E), this also dose not work.

Also, fyi, I did in fact try it(and the string tree method) on a few different B strings, just to see, and it had no effect whatsoever. For BEAD tuning, on a standard 34" bass, all you need is a good set of strings. I've tried it with 5 string sets and standard light guage 4 string sets, all you need is the right strings for you, and a good setup.
 
Reviving old thread here:

My guitar players, after having INSISTED on drop-C tuning, are now deciding to switch to drop-B (BF♯BEG♯C♯). This after I just got rid of my 5 string to accomodate drop-C

See, I dont care for dropped tuning much, I prefer to just play in standard and transpose what they're playing, so at first I tried tuning my five string up to C-standard. After a few weeks I decided this just wasnt comfortable, so I offed my 5 string and got a 4 string jazz, which I upgraded heavily with a new bridge, full shielding job, super-hot Dimarzio pickups and a neck refinish.

Now, they want to do Drop-B, which means I either have to trade out my hard-worked 4 string or sell it for a 5 or 6 string...OR just tune my jazz bass to B standard transpose.

My Jazz sounds so good I think Im just gonna tune down. I was planning on replacing the nut with an ABM adjustable nut, so I'm gonna string the thing up with D'Addario mediums (130 - 55).

I use a very very light touch and prefer high tension, so we'll see how it goes. The neck on this bass is finicky, so we'll see how it takes the change.

will report back next week!