I usually rehearse with keys and drums like this, and use my bass' volume to bring it down. I keep the front end free'd up quite a bit.
Do you lose some highs by running the gain low and master up? I often bring my bass volume down from max as a way to roll off just a bit of the high end and buffer it a little -- kind of poor man's compression. Not sure it woul work the same on the gain/master of the amp, so interested to hear your thoughts. Usually I am running the amp gain as high as is practical, but setting the master lower.

