• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

All Things Must Beat. Share Anything Beatles!!

Freddie Mercury reportedly used the same piano which McCartney used for “Hey Jude” seven years prior to record “Bohemian Rhapsody”. In fact, the piano in question has famously served an array of top-notch performers of the era, including David Bowie, Supertramp, Nilsson, and the Rolling Stones.

Described as a century-old Bechstein Grand Piano, a bit difficult to play but which produced a really genuine and clear sound, the instrument lured famous performers of the day to come to the Trident Studios in London’s Soho district.

It was not just “Hey Jude” and “Bohemian Rhapsody” that were recorded with its help, but albums such as the Beatles’ “White Album”, David Bowie’s “Space Oddity” and George Harrison’s solo album “All Things Must Pass” to name just three. Other top-selling singles that used the legendary Bechstein include Mary Hopkins’ “Those Were the Days” and Lou Reed’s “Perfect Day”.
 
3AE70C1C-3DC3-42CB-B6EF-396BAE03C0E7.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Julian G
Interesting read here. I do love this album, regardless of the “weird” songs.

Ranking the songs on The Beatles' 'White Album' in order of greatness


Well, the article was interesting until they didn't list "Revolution 9" as the worst 'song', to use the term extremely loosely. Then I seemed to simply disagree with all it had to say. And the idea that John was 'hurt' to be left out of "Why Don't We Do It In The Road" seems the acme of irony when all I've read seems he'd rather just be with Yoko than anything else. Sorry. Just my $0.02.
.
 
Well, the article was interesting until they didn't list "Revolution 9" as the worst 'song', to use the term extremely loosely. Then I seemed to simply disagree with all it had to say. And the idea that John was 'hurt' to be left out of "Why Don't We Do It In The Road" seems the acme of irony when all I've read seems he'd rather just be with Yoko than anything else. Sorry. Just my $0.02.
.
Totally agree. I rather like the song Goodnight. That’s why I said it was an interesting read.
 
  • Like
Reactions: G-Dog and woodyng2
I hated the White Album when it first came out. I hated it in the 70's, 80's, 90's, 2000's, and the 2010's, all way up to 2020, where I finally made peace with it. When it came out I was disappointed in the Beatles and I thought that they had left me.:sour:

The only songs I will listen to are:
Back In The U.S.S.R
Dear Prudence
Glass Onion
Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da
While My Guitar Gently Sleeps
Happiness Is A Warm Gun
Martha My Dear
I'm So Tired
Blackbird
I Will
Julia
Birthday
Savoy Truffle

I think all of the other songs on the album are crap!

Your opinion may vary. :)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: StereoPlayer
I hated the White Album when it first came out. I hated it in the 70's, 80's, 90's, 2000's, and the 2010's, all way up to 2020, where I finally made peace with it. When it came out I was disappointed in the Beatles and I thought that they had left me.:sour:

The only songs I will listen to are:
Back In The U.S.S.R
Dear Prudence
Glass Onion
Ob-La-Di Ob-La-Da
While My Guitar Gently Sleeps
Happiness Is A Warm Gun
Martha My Dear
I'm So Tired
Blackbird
I Will
Julia
Birthday
Savoy Truffle

I think all of the other songs on the album are crap!

Your opinion may vary. :)


Of course, opinions will vary. That's what life is all about. Though I will agree that you have picked the cream of the crop.

However, I think you may be living up to your 'Grumpy Old Man' subtitle and missing out on some pretty good stuff, IMHO. Such as . . . .

Piggies - took me a while to warm up to. But, when I read of George's friendship with the
Monty Python chaps it made a lot more sense to me. Very caustic words, and sound effects, amidst lavish baroque orchestration is not my favorite, but holds some appeal.​
Rocky Raccoon - I loved immediately, not the least because it was in tune with my guitar and
easy to play. I tried out for "The Sound of Music" in high school with it and got a speaking part! Maybe I should have started with a tenor verse instead of the spoken opening? :roflmao:
I Will - is a Landmark Ballad, suitable for duet, that my wife & I have sung together since
meeting in '70, and beautifully recorded by many pros! Paul hummed the bass line!
Mother Nature's Son - very cool 'hippie' song, man, that almost reprises Fool On The Hill, but
with more overtly calming, meditative imagery. (before being jarred into . . . .​
Everybody's...Monkey & Helter Skelter - are two of the heaviest rockers, Ever!! Each has been
said to have defined Heavy Metal Rock, but no covers have ever done them justice.​
Sexy Sadie & Long, Long, Long - both mystically mesmerizing message pieces suitably from
the Maharishi's retreat in Rishikesh and chock full of the requisite images and mantras.​
Revolution 1 - the laid back, surfy singalong, bah-bah-Beach Boys version of the hit single!
Fab! One of a few songs that I think works, message-wise, in both different styles.​
Honey Pie - another dance hall "oldie", a la When...64, that Paul does well. They grow on me.
Savoy Truffle - George poking fun at his friend Clapton's toothache! More fun than Piggies!
Cry, Baby, Cry - is a promising mashup of some of John's & Paul's miscellaneous bits that float
together nicely, for a while, before simply winding down. Still, I find it intriguing.​
Good Night - a lovely benevolent benediction to this real hodge-podge of musical styles.
Kind of a soothing Let It Be, if you will, suitable even for kiddies bedtime. (And I did often sing it to mine.) It's also a harbinger of Ringo solo albums yet to come where he often sings to orchestras and big bands, in addition to his rockers.​

But to rank them in order? Fuhgeddaboudit! I can cruise along just fine in the order they came in. But, when listening, I always find something else to do during Revolution 9, preferably in another room, and sometimes during Wild Honey Pie.
.
 
Last edited:
Speaking with 60 Minutes, Paul McCartney described it as “embarrassing” that he didn’t read music. But what he said next revealed he wasn’t too embarrassed about it. “I don’t read music or write music. None of us did in The Beatles. We did some good stuff, though.”

Of course, Paul, John, and George always wrote down their lyrics, chords, and other notes that allowed them to keep track of their songs. Once they finished a track and were ready to send it off to the publisher, someone in the studio would transcribe it into sheet music for them.

The Beatles aren’t alone in not reading music. Elvis Presley, one of John’s favorite musicians, also didn’t read scores. And Jimi Hendrix, widely considered a great guitar player, didn’t either.
 
Wish I could narrow my list down that short! :D:laugh::roflmao:
.

I can't do it either, their catalog of great songs is way too deep to settle on a static list of faves. I'm not complaining though! From Day 1 that catalog has given me a lifetime's worth of great music to enjoy, and still going strong. I can't say that about any other group. :thumbsup:
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Owl and G-Dog
Just came across this thread now and have read various comments just wanted to add that from The White Album surely "Everything.....Monkey" deserves merit for the best use ever of a bell in a song!

I try to explain to my kids about the Beatles and how they changed and shaped music for the future - strangely the youngest at 17 seems to get it more than any of the other 7!
 
Just came across this thread now and have read various comments just wanted to add that from The White Album surely "Everything.....Monkey" deserves merit for the best use ever of a bell in a song!

I try to explain to my kids about the Beatles and how they changed and shaped music for the future - strangely the youngest at 17 seems to get it more than any of the other 7!


"Everybody's Got Something To Hide Except Me And My Monkey" is quite the conundrum, alright. For detractors, it does seem to be about heroin. And John says it's about his addiction to Yoko. Of course, George says it's a quote from the Maharishi. Either way, it's the definitive answer, long before the demand, for more cowbell!

Take heart, Jules. You never know how deeply ingrained your Beatles training of your children really is. I thought my efforts with my 5 kids were all for naught for many, many years. But now, with the youngest at 42, I'm seeing them teach their children The Beatles! And my oldest granddaughter's favorite movie is "Across The Universe". So, I rest assured that even her daughter is hearing them now in her formative years.

"And, in the end, the love you take ...
is equal to the love you make"

.
 
Just came across this thread now and have read various comments just wanted to add that from The White Album surely "Everything.....Monkey" deserves merit for the best use ever of a bell in a song!

I try to explain to my kids about the Beatles and how they changed and shaped music for the future - strangely the youngest at 17 seems to get it more than any of the other 7!

I've always said to those who were not around at the time: In order to totally understand it all you would have to have known what life was like for us up to that point in time. The world was a very, very different place back then.