• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

An idea that's been floating in my head for a while

Well, see...you just named 4 horn players.
For some reason, horn players + pianists usually get mentioned 'first'.

I'm betting Wes' name would be near the top if Jazz Guitar was the topic. ;)
 
Nice exchange of ideas; here's a spin:

I pick up CD's on the Naxos label of (one of)
my favorite genres, the classical guitar. These cost
$5 each The compositions range from Bach, etc.
to the more obscure, like Regondi or Fernando Sor.
To say the least, the performances are absolutely
astounding, virtuosity that is mind-boggling-
(You should hear this guitarist play Paganini!)
Although the artists that record for Naxos are acclaimed in their small realm, the music buying & listening public at large doesn't even think for a second about this idiom for the most part.
Mingus mentioned this in his autobiography-
He said that at a point in his career when he was becoming acclaimed and considered "bad",
he had an epiphany of sorts by hearing a string quartet playing on the radio- and was taken by the fact that no mention was made of the performers,
the music spoke for itself.
OK that's my point I guess- famous or not, the music speaks for itself.
Now if I rambled a bit, forgive me- just got back from a gig - a wedding, no less- (money very decent, food was GREAT, & even some of the music was cool:D !
 
Yeah, ON A WHOLE, I would say Classical Music is about the composer. Then, the conductor.
...unless it's a concerto. ;)

Jazz is more of a performers' medium. The individual player makes the choice about how to pull off a certain piece of music...