• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Any Fingerstyle Punk Players

One band: A Wilhelm Scream. That guy plays fingerstyle and he just leaves me in awe everytime i hear him play. Listen to the horse of the album career suicide and you see what i mean.

I play fingerstyle only. Never liked picks and the clunk sound they make. Its hard to get used to playing fast muted lines with your fingers but once you learn how to fly it feels really great to do so. Practice is all it takes.
 
Exactly. I play in a punk cover band, Dead Boys, Pistols, Ramones, Stooges, Plasmatics, Devo etc., whenever I play with a pick I miss the full impact of my fingers and find the tone of the bass gets buried a bit by the rest of the band. I can get away with a pick on the Ramones songs but it still sounds fuller with my fingers. I've always been a finger player and I love some pick style bass players, but I can play quicker and cleaner over the fretboard with my fingers. I dont really care about emulating the players tone on these songs whether its pick or fingers, I just try to remain faithful to the style or groove of the lines and make it sound as tight and full as possible with my two hands.
 
I think he means to say:
"There is a plethora of posters on this fine forum that enjoy playing their electric basses with their fingers as opposed to a plectrum, and they claim that should they ever find themselves in a musical ensemble which is of the 'punk' tradition, they can emulate the sound of a plectrum with their digits. In fact, they are so certain of this ability that you will not spy a plectrum between their digits! However, I have yet to see or hear irrefutable proof of this claim."

wow thats really well written. do you want to rewrite the whole post too?
 
I was under the same assumption that most punk players used picks. I started off with a pick in punk bands but moved to fingers when I started getting better and found I liked how it sounded rounder. I still like the cut of using a pick. I couldn't imagine Matt Freeman using his fingers on some of my favorite Rancid tracks. I'm sure he did both, but most of the time I would assume he used a pick to get that great cut he had on "Out Come the Wolves". That being said, I'm in a top 40 cover band now covering Lady Gaga so that wipes away any crediblity I've ever had.