TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
My latest band had good luck finding a second guitarist using bandmix.
I've had a lot of success replying to ads on CL. My location might help with it, but if you figure out how to find posts made by smart people you can find some great music and people.
I haven't had to post my own ads for things yet, so can't comment on that.
We've tried Bandmix a number of times, seems to be a bit better at narrowing down the type of musician you're looking for, but most of what we've seen is someone who gets to the audition and doesn't quite live up to the profile they've created for the web page.

Tempted to try BM. Do you like it over all?
"Is it really populated by the bottom feeders or is there real talent out there and I've just been unlucky so far?"
Judging people based on their non-musical career path when looking for musicians? Really?
I had a guitarist last year that was a corporate sales mgr., lost one, then another guitarist and eventually a solid drummer over him not showing up for practice.
It's Deja Vu now with a consultant for a major corporation, making it impossible to schedule an audition for a second guitar and the drummer that was previously very reliable is suddenly too busy as well.
Both drummers I've mentioned are career professionals and have been perfectly reliable well within reason.
Some of those musicians where found on CL, which is just another advertising medium that has pretty much taken the place of newspaper classifieds. Who's making sure "bottom feeders" don't get through the door at your gigs? You can and will find flakes in every walk of life.
Yeah, it's just bad luck so far. The right people will turn up if we beat the bushes long enough. The music scene here isn't as vibrant as it once was, so there is a lack of musicians in the area. It just takes time....You gotta pay yer dues if you wanna play the blues.You've just been unlucky and or are just in a crappy place for live music. You really have to get to a region that has a night life and "scene." For instance, very professional bands and acts pop up in the Seattle area, I imagine it's 10x better in a city like New York or L.A.
Actually, NYC SUCKS for this. It's all the worst flakes and dreamers mentioned, just more of them. It's always needles in haystacks. Anywhere.

Most of the bands I've joined and most of the people I've hired came from craigslist. You just have to be patient and judicious in your choices. Go with your gut whether you're joining or hiring. I can generally weed out the ghetto ones on the phone on first contact. If not, the audition confirms one way or the other.I am in an acoustic band at the moment, but we're without a gig and no prospects for the near future. We'd only be playing once a week or so anyway.
I decided to keep tabs on the local Craigslist for musicians. I'm looking for something to do on the side and if the acoustic gig doesn't work out, maybe something more steady.
I don't mean to sound insulting to folks who put ads on Craigslist, but the 3-4 hits I've gotten so far have been, well, a little on the "ghetto" side, if you get my drift.
For anyone who has used Craigslist looking for bass gigs, is this the norm or have I just been unlucky?
I'm seriously at a loss then and can only assume there's some kind of magic in all the rain up here, because I've had tremendous opportunities and good luck on CL. I'm not even that good, more of a second call guy, particularly with some of the jazz acts I've the privilege to play with.
Certainly to toot my own horn and perhaps provide some proof...
I met this gal on CL and signed up with her project. The ad was looking for a bass man to be on her album and when I heard she exceeded her kickstarter goal and heard her sound, I was in the studio with her the next week, seemingly.
Samples from the album available on the big sitrtibutors like iTunes...
Big tour this summer possibly including Ireland or London where we're getting some airplay. And if that wasn't enough. her mother is a heavy hitter in the jazz scene and tapped me for The Cascade Jazz Quartet.
That was just one response to a single CL ad. Don't give up, never give up, keep on groovin'!
Gotta chime in here to say it's not all that bad. Again, just know how to look for quality. I do agree that there's more noise though, since there are more people.Actually, NYC SUCKS for this. It's all the worst flakes and dreamers mentioned, just more of them. It's always needles in haystacks. Anywhere.
Gotta chime in here to say it's not all that bad. Again, just know how to look for quality. I do agree that there's more noise though, since there are more people.