As a predominantly plug-n-player, the gigs I've been doing have been pretty old-school blues, soul, classic rock and outlaw country.
This goes for bass and guitar, though not so much guitar these days. Still, as a guitarist playing the same music styles, the tones I've preferred from accompanying bassists have been from fellow plug-n-players. Those who've brought a lot of effects to the gig have sometimes left me with a slight sense of disconnection from the groove.
OTOH, a friend I've heard with his band doing current pop and recent-to-modern funk sounds 100% right using lots of effects.
This goes for bass and guitar, though not so much guitar these days. Still, as a guitarist playing the same music styles, the tones I've preferred from accompanying bassists have been from fellow plug-n-players. Those who've brought a lot of effects to the gig have sometimes left me with a slight sense of disconnection from the groove.
OTOH, a friend I've heard with his band doing current pop and recent-to-modern funk sounds 100% right using lots of effects.