• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Assembling your own basses vs buying production basses vs modding

Which do you prefer? (you may select as many choices as you wish)

  • Buy production basses and leave them stock

    Votes: 252 40.9%
  • Buy production basses and perform mods

    Votes: 304 49.4%
  • Buy separate components and assemble basses to your exact spec

    Votes: 216 35.1%
  • Make basses from scratch including cutting the wood for bodies/necks

    Votes: 51 8.3%
  • Peel carrots to your exact specifications

    Votes: 68 11.0%

  • Total voters
    616
Hey there TB'ers! :)

I've been playing bass since 1972, and for most of those years, I always bought production basses and left them stock for the most part. I've mostly owned Fenders and Rickenbackers over the years, including a few Fender Custom Shops.

For most of those years, it never dawned on me to assemble my own basses. For some reason, my brain was programmed to think that buying production basses was the only viable option (for me, anyway).

A few years ago, I reached a point where I wasn't quite satisfied with production basses, primarily because none of them had the exact components that I wanted. Since resale value is of zero interest or concern to me at this point in my life (a 63 year old retired civil engineer), and because I love to tinker at home putting things together, I made the decision a couple of years ago to start assembling my own basses using the exact components that I wanted. (Btw, I'm not talented enough to cut my own wood for bass bodies and necks, so I bought bass bodies and necks.) What I ended up with is a set of basses that I absolutely love! I am so pleased with the decision that I made to assemble my own basses because I now have exactly what I want. :thumbsup:

Now, I realize that assembling basses is not what everyone wants to do. We all like different things, which is the way it should be. But for me (and I'm only talking about *ME* here), the preference that I held for decades of buying production basses changed to a preference for assembling my own basses using the exact components that I wanted. Since I experienced this "shift" in preference (which honestly caught me by surprise), and the end result was a very high level of happiness and satisfaction (for me), I was wondering, do any of my fellow and/or fellowette TB'ers have a preference of buying production basses vs assembling them to achieve satisfaction? (That is the original reason I started this thread....to ask TB'ers that question.)

Of course, in between those two options would be to take a production bass, and perform whatever mods you wish. That is indeed what I did with my Ric 4003S shown in the middle of the pic below. That is the only production bass that I own. All I did there is swap out the stock neck pickup for a Nordenbacker. The other four Fender basses shown in the pic (two J's on the left and two P's on the right) were assembled by me using high end components of my choice (eg, USA Fender necks with 1.5" nut width, Lollar pickups, Hipshot Kickass bridges, Fender Deluxe Schaller Lite tuners, either USACG or Warmoth bodies, top shelf wiring harnesses/pots including a series/parallel switch on one of the J's, and in the case of the bass on the right, custom paint by Guitarpaintguys). Each of the Fender basses ended up costing me around $1400 to $1500 in components. IMO, they are better (for me) than the $3000 Custom Shop Fenders that I owned in the past because these basses have the exact components that I want (plus they were assembled by a really nice guy! :D:D:D)

Now that I think about it as I'm typing this, I think I will create a poll to gauge what TB'ers prefer! :thumbsup:

Please vote, and also please post explaining why you voted the way you did. Bass pics are also encouraged! :)

EDIT1: see my post #29 for parts sourcing info! :thumbsup:

EDIT2: see my post #46 for info on the 5-space rack.

My basses.jpg
 
Last edited:
I looked at buying parts to build a bass & it would be a lot cheap to buy one already assembled (pre-owned) & then just change what you don't like about it.
The important part is the neck, find something with a good, stiff neck & you're golden.

This one cost me just under $200 USD:
That's even after changing almost everything:
bridge
machine-heads
pots & knobs
neck
 
I have a parts bass with a P body and a J neck which I could never find from Fender. I did consider a Lakland Skyline Duck Dunn [not sure what they call it now] but this was much cheaper/ :thumbsup:

I too prefer J necks, which is what I have on my two P basses (and of course my two J basses). I used to own a USA Lakie Duck Dunn (1.5" nut width). I believe Fender's fairly recent "postmodern" series of P basses came with J necks.
 
Last edited:
The important part is the neck, find something with a good, stiff neck & you're golden.

+1 :thumbsup:

I agree that the neck is the most important component. For the four Fender basses that I assembled, by far the most expensive components were the USA Fender necks. I think each neck cost me somewhere around $500 to $600. They came with the frets and fret markers already installed, and the headstocks were pre-drilled for the tuners.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Killed_by_Death
I'd keep clear of doing carbon necks myself but everything else is fair game :-)

Take the humble P-bass. Why folks buy mass production models is beyond me. It's so much easier to get exactly what you want going DIY. I wanted a pine slab 51 style wih chunky neck. Even with a custom wound 28k pickup this just broke the £220 mark.
Telebass (1).JPG


Cabronita with mahogany body,TV Jones pickup,Fender deluxe bridge and tort PG. £275.
PB110095 (2).JPG
 
I'd keep clear of doing carbon necks myself but everything else is fair game :)

Take the humble P-bass. Why folks buy mass production models is beyond me. It's so much easier to get exactly what you want going DIY. I wanted a pine slab 51 style wih chunky neck. Even with a custom wound 28k pickup this just broke the £220 mark.
View attachment 3647274

Cabronita with mahogany body,TV Jones pickup,Fender deluxe bridge and tort PG. £275.
View attachment 3647280

saWEET collection!!! :thumbsup:
 
Hey there TB'ers! :)

I've been playing bass since 1972, and for most of those years, I always bought production basses and left them stock for the most part. I've mostly owned Fenders and Rickenbackers over the years, including a few Fender Custom Shops.

For most of those years, it never dawned on me to assemble my own basses. For some reason, my brain was programmed to think that buying production basses was the only viable option (for me, anyway).

A few years ago, I reached a point where I wasn't quite satisfied with production basses, primarily because none of them had the exact components that I wanted. Since resale value is of zero interest or concern to me at this point in my life (a 63 year old retired civil engineer), and because I love to tinker at home putting things together, I made the decision a couple of years ago to start assembling my own basses using the exact components that I wanted. (Btw, I'm not talented enough to cut my own wood for bass bodies and necks, so I bought bass bodies and necks.) What I ended up with is a set of basses that I absolutely love! I am so pleased with the decision that I made to assemble my own basses because I now have exactly what I want. :thumbsup:

Now, I realize that assembling basses is not what everyone wants to do. We all like different things, which is the way it should be. But for me (and I'm only talking about *ME* here), the preference that I held for decades of buying production basses changed to a preference for assembling my own basses using the exact components that I wanted. Since I experienced this "shift" in preference (which honestly caught me by surprise), and the end result was a very high level of happiness and satisfaction (for me), I was wondering, do any of my fellow and/or fellowette TB'ers have a preference of buying production basses vs assembling them? (That is the original reason I started this thread....to ask TB'ers that question.)

Of course, in between those two options would be to take a production bass, and perform whatever mods you wish. That is indeed what I did with my Ric 4003S shown in the middle of the pic below. That is the only production bass that I own. All I did there is swap out the stock neck pickup for a Nordenbacker. The other four Fender basses shown in the pic (two J's on the left and two P's on the right) were assembled by me using high end components of my choice (eg, USA Fender necks with 1.5" nut width, Lollar pickups, Hipshot Kickass bridges, Fender Deluxe Schaller Lite tuners, either USACG or Warmoth bodies, top shelf wiring harnesses/pots including a series/parallel switch on one of the J's, and in the case of the bass on the right, custom paint by Guitarpaintguys.) Each of the Fender basses ended up costing me around $1400 to $1500 in components. IMO, they are better (for me) than the $3000 Custom Shop Fenders that I owned in the past because these basses have the exact components that I want (plus they were assembled by a really nice guy! :D:D:D)

Now that I think about it as I'm typing this, I think I will create a poll to gauge what TB'ers prefer! :thumbsup:

View attachment 3647177

Personally … I love modding basses and building parts basses … I have 16 basses and none of them is stock.

DSCF1213.JPG


720.JPG


DSCF1053.JPG

F0711.jpg
 
There are SO many different components available nowdays, it's not hard to buy everything to your own tastes/needs and assemble something exactly like you want.

And, it's not that much of a crapshoot to get the sound/ feel you're looking for.. no more than trying to find that magic in a production instrument, in my opinion. The only real downside might be resale value of a "mutt" bass with no single-brand pedigree.

If you assemble one out of components, and dont like (for example) the electronics, you can swap them with something you might like better. It's a GREAT learning process.
 
I would concur that the neck is crucial.

Both of my keeper "Fenders" are just necks I like ('78 P & Allparts J) that have seen a bunch of different bodies & pickups; I just keep swapping till I'm fully satisfied. I love the classic Fender designs for how accommodating they are for tinkering.

I've mulled doing a brand new parts build from scratch but when you price that all out, it can quickly add up to over $1000 for a no-name. Scavenging used components makes a lot of sense (though I did recently run out of patience, break down & buy a new body from Warmoth).

I might leave certain other axes bone stock in part because:
  • Already a masterpiece as-is.
  • Drop-in upgrades scarce & expensive.
  • Other mods might require woodworking and/or soldering beyond my skill level & be irreversible, with uncertain results.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SactoBass
despite kb's exception to the rule, building or modding to taste can get pricey, especially if it's not a guaranteed perfect build. I prefer finding great cheaper basses that don't need changes, or the few changes made will make exceptional improvements with hopefully 0-little noticeable. my fab $100 LB11 is quite good to go, but being such a fine bass which can be had all day for peanuts I'm willing to risk it by throwing in a pair of old nasty mudbuckers at the bridge and neck along with a Deaf-Eddie FAT-O-Caster and similar indiscriminate tone enhancers. swap out the sturdy chrome bridge for something in black and let the shiny muddies make their twin visual and aural statement for far less than a 1K+ vintage short scale Gibson which I'm not sure is even suitable for me. but I want that big sonic monkey off my back and a simple PU /wiring mod on a bass I already could give me my ultimate player for half of what a decent parts bass would cost.
Deaf Eddie - Guitar Whacko!
upload_2019-12-29_10-27-46.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rafar and SactoBass
There are SO many different components available nowdays, it's not hard to buy everything to your own tastes/needs and assemble something exactly like you want.

And, it's not that much of a crapshoot to get the sound/ feel you're looking for.. no more than trying to find that magic in a production instrument, in my opinion. The only real downside might be resale value of a "mutt" bass with no single-brand pedigree.

If you assemble one out of components, and dont like (for example) the electronics, you can swap them with something you might like better. It's a GREAT learning process.

Biiiiig +1 :thumbsup:
 
I guess it depends if you ever plan to sell it. You could spend a ton of money putting together a Warmoth bass and then find its practically worthless when you try to sell it.

Yes, if resale value is an important aspect to the owner, then other options may be more prudent. As stated in my OP, resale value happens to be of zero importance to me at this point in my life. :thumbsup: