• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

B C F# B(?)E(?)/BCFBbEb Tuning... I am losing my mind.

Howdy,

It's been a journey from guitar land here and I think I'm getting close to buying my first bass for tracking. It took a moment to realize that I'm not making chords so I have less to worry about to compete with a rack full of guitars. However, what doesn't really change for me, is the necessity of having the ability to play open notes. Tone is in the fingers as we know in both camps, and a large part of some of the playing styles is being able to bang on an open note and hammer on around the 12th. I want to be able to double on guitar drop C, B & F#.

I've also paid attention to how we hear these low notes. For instance, anything in guitar played below a C starts to get pretty muddy, even with extended range guitars. There's all sorts of weird overtones that start to muck things up. And with that, you end up adapting how you play, what amps you use etc. Long story short, I consider drop C to be the most important lower note for how am I constructing my bass mindset.

Taking inspiration from Jeff Matz, he is tuned C F Bb Eb. The next note I am most interested and concerned with is drop B on guitar. While it does not resolve nearly as nice as C, taking a look at groups like Fear Factory, they are taking that drop B on the 5th string. Now a Dingwall isn't in the budget. But a ehb1005ms is. That goes up to 35" scale, and is multiscale.

If I'm understanding this, the bass notes for playing with Meshuggah at F# are further up the neck than playing an octave below B\C stuff on guitar. Meaning I'll use my 5th, and 4th string open for guitars in Drop B or Drop C (since this will all resolve itself much nicer because of the harmoics), but then with F\F# stuff I'm actually using the 3rd string open to "double up." That since the guitar is so muddy, so low, I'm actually supporting it rather than providing a lower register.

So that puts me at

B C F\F# (either or is fine) and I'm unsure of what ideas of how I should space out the top two strings.

I think this puts me at reasonbly as far as string gauge

145
115
95
70
50

So I'm trying to be able to accomate material similar to Meshuggah's Obzen album (do not need to cover the sub A stuff) in F\F#, High on Fire in Drop C and Fear Factory's Demanufacture in Drop B (which if I understand this right is played lower than Meshuggah from a bass perspective).

How I tune the top 2 strings is less important and I'd be interested to hear recommendations. I think if I tune in 4ths the top 2 would be same as Matz tuning, but if I go down to F, then they go from flat to B/E.

For regular old Drop D and maybe even some C# stuff, I want to mess around with that tasty Squire IV.

Any help is appreciated, sorry for the mess!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jawamac
And if you have a 4 string bass and want to go low, string it BEAD. For the most part bass players don't bother with open tunings.
If you REALLY need open strings, a capo does wonders. If it's for originals, just agree with the guitar players.
By essence, open strings change following the needs so if you go this road you may have to retune often.
 
And if you have a 4 string bass and want to go low, string it BEAD. For the most part bass players don't bother with open tunings.
If you REALLY need open strings, a capo does wonders. If it's for originals, just agree with the guitar players.
By essence, open strings change following the needs so if you go this road you may have to retune often.

I entirely understand this for live, but this is for tracking. And since I'm a guitar guy I am trying to avoid having a rack full of bass guitars or restringing 10 times a week to throw in a string for A\B tuning etc.
 
I've been playing bass for more than 50 years and I don't understand your post. Bassists need to play notes, not chords. Whether you tune BEAD, BEADG, CFBbEbAb, or some other combination of strings tuned in conventional fourths, you will be able to use conventional fingerings to sound the notes you want to be able to hear. If your interest is solely in "tracking," why not play the parts on a keyboard?
 
I entirely understand this for live, but this is for tracking. And since I'm a guitar guy I am trying to avoid having a rack full of bass guitars or restringing 10 times a week to throw in a string for A\B tuning etc.
You can play absolutely anything on a bass tuned EADG or BEAD. Open tunings aren't a requirement in any way.
 
I've been playing bass for more than 50 years and I don't understand your post. Bassists need to play notes, not chords. Whether you tune BEAD, BEADG, CFBbEbAb, or some other combination of strings tuned in conventional fourths, you will be able to use conventional fingerings to sound the notes you want to be able to hear. If your interest is solely in "tracking," why not play the parts on a keyboard?

Because tone is in the fingers, for real. And I can't hammer on then.

e.g. 0-H12 is not the same as
-5
0-

For live, I get it. No one is going to notice, it's all about having a reasonable load in.
 
There is a bias towards standard tuning on TB , which I freely admit to being part of, so I have no advice directly.

But there are players here who understand the desire to use alternate tunings for adjective metal and similar styles. Occasionally they chime in with helpful advice about considerations like string gauges and such. You might try searching for some posts

here's a few from a quick search

? For those who play with guitarists in drop C
Which string gauge for C# G# C# F#?
Covering multiple low tunings
 
Because tone is in the fingers, for real. And I can't hammer on then.

e.g. 0-H12 is not the same as
-5
0-

For live, I get it. No one is going to notice, it's all about having a reasonable load in.

I understand that for the use of open strings these tunings can be handy. But you want your tuning match several open string tunings on one bass. That’s not going to work. Just choose a fourths tuning that is the most used in the music that you want to play.
 
Because tone is in the fingers, for real. And I can't hammer on then.

e.g. 0-H12 is not the same as
-5
0-

For live, I get it. No one is going to notice, it's all about having a reasonable load in.
Hammering fretted notes is a thing. And since you're in a studio nobody prevents you from using a capo or retuning for any song. I'd like to help but I don't understand the dilemma.
 
I'm with @Jazz Ad : tune to B, and use a capo at the 1st fret for the songs in C. Easy-peasy. I do it often.

A guitarist shouldn't have to come to a bass forum to learn how to use a capo.

I was open to this, but someone mentioned this effectively lowers the scale length (since you're moving the "nut"). Normally not an issue except tuning down 2 whole steps on the 4th string. Unless I'm thinking about this wrong.

I guess another way to frame this, is outside of this being weird and atypical... is there really a problem with the tuning outside of the fact that it's not in typical fourths?
 
You can tune however you like. You just need to relearn your fingerboard (and your scales and arpeggios) for every different tuning. If this does not bother you, go for it! (but keep in mind the strings are designed to have optimal behavior for their nominal tuning).
 
  • Like
Reactions: 12BitSlab
Howdy,

It's been a journey from guitar land here and I think I'm getting close to buying my first bass for tracking. It took a moment to realize that I'm not making chords so I have less to worry about to compete with a rack full of guitars. However, what doesn't really change for me, is the necessity of having the ability to play open notes. Tone is in the fingers as we know in both camps, and a large part of some of the playing styles is being able to bang on an open note and hammer on around the 12th. I want to be able to double on guitar drop C, B & F#.

I've also paid attention to how we hear these low notes. For instance, anything in guitar played below a C starts to get pretty muddy, even with extended range guitars. There's all sorts of weird overtones that start to muck things up. And with that, you end up adapting how you play, what amps you use etc. Long story short, I consider drop C to be the most important lower note for how am I constructing my bass mindset.

Taking inspiration from Jeff Matz, he is tuned C F Bb Eb. The next note I am most interested and concerned with is drop B on guitar. While it does not resolve nearly as nice as C, taking a look at groups like Fear Factory, they are taking that drop B on the 5th string. Now a Dingwall isn't in the budget. But a ehb1005ms is. That goes up to 35" scale, and is multiscale.

If I'm understanding this, the bass notes for playing with Meshuggah at F# are further up the neck than playing an octave below B\C stuff on guitar. Meaning I'll use my 5th, and 4th string open for guitars in Drop B or Drop C (since this will all resolve itself much nicer because of the harmoics), but then with F\F# stuff I'm actually using the 3rd string open to "double up." That since the guitar is so muddy, so low, I'm actually supporting it rather than providing a lower register.

So that puts me at

B C F\F# (either or is fine) and I'm unsure of what ideas of how I should space out the top two strings.

I think this puts me at reasonbly as far as string gauge

145
115
95
70
50

So I'm trying to be able to accomate material similar to Meshuggah's Obzen album (do not need to cover the sub A stuff) in F\F#, High on Fire in Drop C and Fear Factory's Demanufacture in Drop B (which if I understand this right is played lower than Meshuggah from a bass perspective).

How I tune the top 2 strings is less important and I'd be interested to hear recommendations. I think if I tune in 4ths the top 2 would be same as Matz tuning, but if I go down to F, then they go from flat to B/E.

For regular old Drop D and maybe even some C# stuff, I want to mess around with that tasty Squire IV.

Any help is appreciated, sorry for the mess!


Nice man!:bassist: