• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass B Lang Cutaway Bass

Any thoughts on this? Supposed to be a Benedikt Lang (Mittenwald?) circa 1930. Selling for $2600. Ply or carved?

f_41235902_1724830435790_bg_processed.jpg.webp
f_41235902_1724830589387_bg_processed.jpg.webp
f_41235902_1724830550573_bg_processed.jpg.webp
f_41235902_1724830476981_bg_processed.jpg.webp
 

Attachments

  • f_41235902_1724830146212_bg_processed.jpg.webp
    f_41235902_1724830146212_bg_processed.jpg.webp
    26 KB · Views: 7
  • f_41235902_1724830435790_bg_processed.jpg.webp
    f_41235902_1724830435790_bg_processed.jpg.webp
    62 KB · Views: 8
  • f_41235902_1724830435790_bg_processed.jpg.webp
    f_41235902_1724830435790_bg_processed.jpg.webp
    62 KB · Views: 12
I don't know anything about pricing, but based on the longitudinal cracks in the top, I would guess at least that much is solid.

The scroll volute is just broken off... it was carved, not a glued-on applique piece. That would take a pretty hard shot.
 
The cracks make me think that the top and back and likely not-laminate. This is almost definitely a Framus. They're the only brand I know that made cutaway basses. The ribs look shallow to me. Visually, I would not expect this bass to sound as good as well made, modern student bass and aside from the novelty, cutaways don't seem to offer any playing advantage on a doublebass. It won't help you avoid thumb position, like it would on a guitar instrument.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RSBBass
This has some history of the form (price is in Australian dollars, about a 1/3rd higher than USD)

 
  • Like
Reactions: james condino
I've played a bass like this before. In Japan both the companies Oriente and Chaki have made them. It's true that the cutaways are useless, however the one I played had a slightly different shape to the cutaway which probably is a little bit of an improvement over the original Framus design. Here's a picture of the Oriente, (fully carved, the player's face is blurred out, and the pic was taken with an old phone camera, so poor quality) and a link to a Chaki for sale right now. Seems to be a hybrid. https://jp.mercari.com/item/m15454016850 Asking about 8000USD. He'll have to come down a ways to sell it, I think.

The one I played sounded pretty good, actually, for an instrument in its class. The cutaway was a bit weird, but I think you'd get used to it.
 

Attachments

  • chaki 1.jpg
    chaki 1.jpg
    740.9 KB · Views: 8
Framus, possibly Hofner factory, circa late '40s / early 1950s. White plastic binding and trim, post WW2 tuners. Plywood basses can crack ; often the outside layers do. I had one of these for a couple of years as my first upright bass. It was great. Everyone who didn't own one and never played one was constantly giving me advise on it. They should be priced along the same lines as most mid 20th century plywood basses; ie $2000-low $3000s.

Occasionally you'll find a fully carved version of this model, but I've never seen one of those with the plastic binding. I playe done at SPBGMA in Nasheville a couple of years ago; it was painfully quiet.